Toolsview all

David Stanley Ford

Oklahoma foster system in "severe disarray," lawsuit claims

BY RANDY ELLIS    Comments Comment on this article17
Published: December 4, 2008

TULSA — Nine Oklahoma foster children were bounced around among 176 primary caseworkers because of “severe disarray” within DHS, attorneys said in documents filed Thursday in Tulsa federal court.

Advertisement

The state Department of Human Services also had 125 secondary workers and 190 supervisors overseeing care of those children, documents reveal.

“These staggering numbers reflect severe disarray in the basic oversight of children in state custody,” the children’s attorneys stated.

DHS spokesman George Johnson said Thursday he had not seen the court filings and could not comment.

The disclosures came in an ongoing federal lawsuit filed by attorneys associated with Children’s Rights, a New York-based child advocacy organization.

The attorneys currently represent nine children, but are seeking class action status to represent all children in DHS custody. The attorneys claim DHS has violated the children’s federal constitutional rights by failing to give them proper care and treatment and failing to provide them with safe and adequate living conditions. There are currently about 7,230 Oklahoma children in foster care.

The children’s attorneys have been battling DHS for e-mails by the current and past caseworkers and supervisors assigned to the nine children they represent.

Attorneys for the children claim DHS attorneys have been stonewalling them for months and now want them to pay costs of retrieving the e-mails. The children’s attorneys want DHS to pay.

DHS has provided them with access to some e-mails from their clients’ current caseworkers.

In one May 2007 e-mail, a caseworker said a child’s foster home placement was “doomed ... from the start because of all the family friction, problems, etc.”

In another e-mail, dated September 2007, a caseworker says a foster child was bounced around for weeks among three different shelters “because we have a shortage of foster home resources and had no opening to offer him.”

An adoption request was held up for six months because some paperwork was missing and the case was passed around while an employee was on extended leave, an April 2008 e-mail from a DHS supervisor revealed.

In other e-mails, workers complained about being “very understaffed” and “very overworked,” and having to visit 10 homes in a single day.

Toolsview all

David Stanley Ford





Need Affordable Health Care?
Get Affordable Health Insurance Quotes Online - Plans from $30 / Month
USInsuranceOnline.com

Refinance Now at 4.25% Fixed
No hidden fees-4.4% APR! No obligation. Get 4 free quotes. No SSN req.
MortgageRefinance.LendGo.com


Leave a Comment

Something to say about this topic? Submit a Letter to the Editor online

Thank you for joining our conversations on newsok. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.


Log in below or sign up (it's free).





...but we voted *for* supporting an NBA team! Sad that the $122 million we in Okay See agreed to hand over for support of basketball could have done so much good for so many, that is, if managed properly.
Kevin, Oklahoma City - Dec 5, 2008 at 9:20 am
Thoughtful, actually our great State ranks 22nd for political corruption nationwide. Maybe we will get to be number 1 soon.
Sallie, Del City - Dec 5, 2008 at 8:55 am
I there was a full fledged investigation of the government in this state starting at the bottom and working up, we would have no state agencies or politicians. After reading "The Innocent Man" by John Grisham I was sickened. Knowing Jeff Pierce and the who stinking mess of convicting an inocent man to 18 years in prison, and the people in the Innocent Man who were convicted, I would not want to ever be convicted of a crime in this state. It just makes you wonder just how crooked this state is.
Thoughtful, Oklahoma City - Dec 5, 2008 at 8:50 am
Nancy, OKC....it only took DOK 50 years to find out that old Stipe was crooked and the FBI had to tell the publishers that! Investigative reporting for the DOK is a true oxymoron.
Sallie, Del City - Dec 5, 2008 at 4:32 am
U know what? I think somebody in DHS is stealing money, and I think it's time you did some investigative journalism if you know how to do that.
Nancy, Oklahoma City - Dec 5, 2008 at 1:54 am
Hire some more workers you cheap scrooges. GOD I hate the bureauracy in this town. Our leaders are chinzy dolts. All you rich people's money has to go for ur play-pretties doesn't it? If we poor was to waste our money like you do, you be giving us lectures. Do as I say, don't do as I do. Someday GOD will kick ur behinds good.
Nancy, Oklahoma City - Dec 5, 2008 at 1:52 am
As a current foster parent for over 4 yrs now...I have to say I agree with alot of the previous comments. DHS is wayyyyyy to under funded. There are WAY to many workers who don't care about the children, they just try to make a living...and there are to many people complaining and not helping fix the problems. There are kids in shelters who deserve to be in a home with a loving family. As far as adoption goes, it is sad but true, if the worker does not like you, they will take their time and put you off rather than starting the adoption process as they should. We should all be working together to better the lives of the children of the state of Oklahoma.
Heather, Oklahoma City - Dec 4, 2008 at 9:22 pm
There is absolutly no excuse for how
DHS is run. My son-in-laws nieces were abused sexually and lived in filth. My daughter and her husband took these children and made them a part of their family. DHS harrassed them from day one. The younger one was five and had been in 4 foster homes before they were allowed to come to my daughters house. My daughter's family was treated like they were the evil ones. My daughter spent $7,000 out of her own pocket on dental bills for these children. They could never get DHS to understand that these children were in pain. These children came to them with no clothes, and a huge bag of candy. They were given vouchers for clothes and Walmart said they could not honor them because DHS had not paid them. DHS said go to Dillards. Dillards said no, DHS had not paid them. DHS said wait a couple of weeks. My daughter just bought the clothes so the children could go to school. The younger one was sent to a private Christian School at my son'in-laws expense so she could catch up with her age group. After all living 6 places in 4 months is not exactly the way a child keeps up in school. Fortunately my son-in-law and daughter are able to afford this but, what about the relatives and foster families that can't? After 9 months these children were placed back with the father. They are 13 and 15 now. They have been taken away from him more times than I can count. We have reported them to DHS so many times I can't count that either. They are always returned to the father, the mother gave up custody a long time ago. The live in filth,they have lice, the father does not work, the 13 year old sleeps in the bed with the father. GRRRRRRR!!! this just makes me want to scream. What the H**l is the mattter with this system? The danged social worker left her own 2 year old in the car with the motor running when she came to do an evaluation.
Thoughtful, Oklahoma City - Dec 4, 2008 at 4:37 pm
i agree Susan completely, i hear the word 'policy' on a daily basis in my dealings with DHS and it drives me crazy. DHS is often more concerned with following their own internal policy rather than what is right for the kids. That being said absolutley, positively nothing will or can change without more money from under the dome on Lincoln.
Involved, Yukon - Dec 4, 2008 at 4:26 pm
Complain about DHS. Complain about foster care. Goodness knows, people wouldn't want to actually get involved. Get their hands dirty. Be overworked as a caseworker. Get their heart torn as a CASA worker. Actually care for a foster child. Even to be minimally involved as a respite caregiver.

Being foster parents, we have been challenged, discriminated against (by the "good" people of Okla), threatened by birth-families, accused falsely. But everytime they come to get the kids, we cry after they leave. Our state legislator knows us well because we continually remind him of the foster care crisis.

More caseworkers, more foster families. Great to hear how Mollie passed the checks.....too bad you couldn't get your grandkids but there's alot of other foster kids that would love a have a home like yours.
K.L., warr acres - Dec 4, 2008 at 4:24 pm
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore K.L.
Start with Howard Hendrick, at the top. He should have been removed LONG ago. The entire system is in shambles and needs to be completley re-organized. Something needs to be done about the irresponisbility and the vindictivness of some of the individuals working within DHS. This is just one story among many that happens everyday!
windy, mustang - Dec 4, 2008 at 4:23 pm
The legislature may divide up the funds, but the execs in the agency create a lot of the policies that are causing havoc. I would recommend a very intense audit of the activities because I think a lot of things are going unreported because of "policies." A state agency should be able to cross county lines, but it can't. A DHS worker in Oklahoma County, for instance, isn't allowed to go do interviews in the next county over. Maybe that policy should change and allow the workers to stay with the children more. DHS is broken. It has some great people working for the agency, but the infrastructure itself is faulty. It needs a complete overhaul so it can be rebuilt on an even footing and do the job the agency was created to do - protect children and elderly.
Susan, Oklahoma City - Dec 4, 2008 at 4:17 pm
i work with DHS on a regular basis and i would be first in line with a long list of complaints against the agency but if we are going to throw stones, throw them at the appropriate people, the fine men and women who serve in the Oklahoma legislature. DHS is horribly underfunded and staffed and it is a direct result of our hugely corrupt legilature. Start the stone throwing with Gene Stipe and his cronies from lil dixie and move on down the line.
Involved, Yukon - Dec 4, 2008 at 4:03 pm
I applied to get my 3 Grandkids in foster care and my husband and I passed but my ex daughter in law said she did not want us to get them . They were kept in foster care for 15 months and gave back to her as they got tired of her making waves and causing them trouble not because she suddenly became a non drug user or a good Mother. One was sent to another State ,another was put in an excellent foster home ,the yougest was bounced around and one of the homes he told us the woman hit on him. Of course DHS said she was a great foster Mom .
Mollie, Oklahoma City - Dec 4, 2008 at 3:40 pm
Children are removed from families because of instability, but how can DHS say these kids are in a better place if they are bounced around so many times?
Candace, Lakeland - Dec 4, 2008 at 2:43 pm
AMEN!!!! - as a long time foster parent -- this is just the tip of the iceberg - I hope this group will start interviewing foster parents!! There is so very, very much wrong!!!!
Elizabeth, Oklahoma City - Dec 4, 2008 at 1:47 pm
DHS needs to clean house, starting at the top. This mis-management is inexcusable.
Deann, Crescent - Dec 4, 2008 at 1:19 pm

    News Photo Galleriesview all