Education Station Education Station is your station for news about K-12 and higher education in the state of Oklahoma. We’ll also tell you about trends in education, and occasionally post off-beat or just plain intriguing bits of news.
By the numbers
•Districts can calculate internal figures for their own use. In Putnam City, the district tracks how many students from an eighth-grade class make it to graduation.
•The state uses a formula called the Graduation Leaver Indicator. It accounts for graduates and dropouts.
•The Oversight Board formula is based on how many high school seniors enrolled in the fall graduate at the end of the school year.
The following chart shows how different an outcome these can generate, though all are considered graduation rates. The chart reflects data about the 2005-2006 graduating classes in Putnam City, where two of the AP's "dropout factories” are located.
District calculationState calculationOversight Board calculationPutnamCity High
83.5%
77.8%
96.4%
PutnamCity North
92.8%
85.0%
98.4%
PutnamCity West
69.2%
62.2%*
99.6%
Putnam CitySchool District
82.9%
75.1%
98.0%
*The State Education Department accepted the district's appeal of this figure because of record-keeping problems at the school.
Sources: Putnam City School District, 2006 Oklahoma School Accountability Data Reports, Office of Accountability 2006 School Report Cards
There's a paradox in calling a school a "dropout factory.” Factories have standardized methods of production. Calculating a high school dropout rate is anything but standardized.
In the past two weeks, 21 Oklahoma schools have been put on one list and one Oklahoma district has come off another, both intended to evaluate schools on their graduation rates. But the number of ways to derive such rates and rankings — along with a judge's ruling that state data are unreliable — calls their accuracy into question.
The inconsistencies in reporting methods have educators and legislators alike calling not just for a single