Porter suspended
Porter suspended

Comments Comment on this article44

By Wendy K. Kleinman
Published: January 7, 2008

The Oklahoma City school board voted this morning to suspend Superintendent John Porter.

Featured Video

Advertisement

Days of questions about the turmoil riling the Oklahoma City School District were answered today when the school board met to discuss Superintendent John Porter's future with the district.

On Sunday afternoon, Porter called a press conference to address swirling allegations of fiscal improprieties on his part and counter-accusations that Board Chairman Cliff Hudson is trying to muscle the new superintendent out of his job.

But the back-and-forth between the two officials has taken place in the media, not face to face.

Porter said he was surprised to see coverage of the conflict on the front page of The Oklahoman on Saturday when he returned from vacation, even though part of that story was fueled by a court document filed late Friday by his attorney, Murray Abowitz.

That story is why, he said, he came to the media ahead of today's meeting instead of going directly to school district officials.

As for his previous lack of contact with the district, a point over which Hudson has expressed frustration, Porter said that he was out of town with family.

Hudson said he appreciates that Porter has family responsibilities, but being chief executive of a school district is one of many responsibilities to juggle.

"What we reasonably expected from him ... is that he would pick up the phone and return a call, or he would respond to an e-mail, or he would respond to a Federal Express that was delivered to his home in Maryland” more than two weeks ago, Hudson said.

Conflicting statements
Speaking at John Marshall High School on Sunday, Porter refuted Hudson's description of a meeting in which he said Hudson "demanded that I resign.”

Porter did not provide his account of what happened.

Hudson says he suggested Porter think about resigning following a discussion of harsh criticisms from school principals. He said he does not have the power to demand a superintendent's resignation.

Porter said that he had not heard of any such criticisms until he read reports in The Oklahoman.

But in response, Hudson provided more details of his account of that meeting.

The meeting took place over the lunch hour on Oct. 10, between Hudson, Porter and an outside consultant, Hudson said. The three discussed feedback from administrative staff and principals from a September Organizational Health Indicators survey, he said.

The Oklahoman spoke with that consultant, Leon McLean, on Sunday evening. McLean confirmed that Hudson neither asked for nor demanded Porter's resignation.

McLean, who works for the Organizational Health, Diagnostic and Development Corp. and has consulted with the Oklahoma City School District for five years, agreed to confirm what was not said in the Oct. 10 meeting. Because of confidentiality arrangements, he would not discuss specifics that were discussed.

Other developments
In defending himself against the allegations that have been made public, which involve the purchase of a reading program and travel expenses, Porter mostly repeated what he wrote in his earlier letter to the community — in some cases word-for-word.

He flatly denied misusing or intending to misuse any school funds. He said he always turns over receipts from travel to his staff members, and the school board approved the purchase of the computer program.

But Hudson said that while the board did approve the purchase of the program, Porter did not disclose then that staff members had circumvented the bidding process.

Staff members are responsible for soliciting bids on anything the district purchases to get the lowest price.

According to Hudson, Porter maintains only one vendor sells the type of program in question. However, the district's vendor told investigator Robert McCampbell the names of several competitors, Hudson said.

Separately, Porter also denied any allegations in the copy of the investigation report he received have anything to do with personal relationships or improprieties. Hudson has said not all the district's concerns are related to money matters but has so far declined to elaborate.

‘Stand with me'
At the press conference, Porter was surrounded by Terry Abbott, a friend and the former chief of staff at the U.S. Department of Education, and public relations associates with Saxum Communications.

His wife, Linda, also stood behind him throughout the press conference, and Porter in turn asked the Oklahoma City community to stand by him as well.

"When I came here we embarked on a nine-year plan to make our schools the envy of the nation. .... I ask the community and the school board to stand with me in the battle for better schools,” he said.

Porter will be at the district's administration building, 900 N Klein, to meet with the board this morning, he said.


 

Related Topics: Politics, Local Politics

Toolbar sponsored by: David Stanley Ford

Junkmycar.com
Read this Towing & Wrecking Service's reviews & find Auto Info.
Oklahomacity.Citysearch.com

Oklahoma City Jobs
$30/Hour Work From Home Jobs.View Home Jobs Now! Computer Required.
National-News-Gazette.com

shareView All

Buzz Up!


Leave a Comment

Something to say about this topic? Submit a Letter to the Editor online

Thank you for joining our conversations on newsok. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.


Log in below or sign up (it's free).





Heh. The best thing about such specimens as "T Scott" is that they reinforce every statement made about them as the debate lingers. A complete meltdown into sheer ad hominem then becomes self-reinforcing, as their feeble intellects lash out in rage against the irrefutable facts presented in opposition to their pitiful posted offerings. As I said, quite diverting, especially after a long day dealing with actual adults and legitimate counter-arguments backed up with factual data.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 8, 2008 at 4:56 pm
Jason, don't you have a cross burning to go to or something?
T Scott, Oklahoma City - Jan 8, 2008 at 4:50 pm
By the by, T Scott: how many of them there "xenophobes" have you spotted lately? *snicker*....
Jason, Edmond - Jan 8, 2008 at 3:51 pm
Ah, the continuing personal attacks, the penultimate expression of an ignorant mind at work. I find semi-literates like T Scott quite diverting, actually: they rarely have anything worthwhile to contribute, are easily bested in any factual encounter, and love them their grubby ad hominems. To watch them squirm, froth, and moan their way through a debate topic never fails to amuse.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 8, 2008 at 3:48 pm
Did some mean black man steal your job? Or was it your girlfriend? Or boy friend perhaps? Now back to "relentless diversity mongering".
T Scott, Oklahoma City - Jan 8, 2008 at 3:20 pm
And you are kinda, uh, unable to respond coherently. He may have been hired on account of many things, but in this age of relentless diversity-mongering to suggest that his ethnic background wasn't somewhere in the top three reasons he got hired is either naive or willfully ignorant on your part. I suspect the latter. That is the true tragedy of affirmative action: its toxic effects increase the very divisiveness it is supposed to ameliorate. Now, spotted any of those "xenophobes" that had you so riled up earlier? *snicker*....
Jason, Edmond - Jan 8, 2008 at 2:38 pm
You are kinda funny. Now I get it. I was unaware that Dr. Porter was hired as an affirmative action employee.
T Scott, Oklahoma City - Jan 8, 2008 at 2:13 pm
Once again I will answer: this is a public forum where people are free to comment on the articles posted; this article was posted; I am a person; I am allowed to have an opinion on the matter whether you like it or not. Have I simplified the matter enough for you, or do I need to break out the crayons and start drawing big flowery pictures to match your comprehension levels? Xenophobes? Your grasp of the definition of such big words is as woeful as your understanding of other rather simpler matters: a "xenophobe" is one who is fearful of foreigners, and last I checked Edmond and Oklahoma City were both well within the borders of the Untied States and share a common country. As for the rest, no, T Scott, that absurd hash of pablum closes out of town: criticism of the rancid policy of affirmative action is not "bringing up the race card," it is criticizing said policy. It would do you race-baiters well to learn the difference, but, then, how would you be able to debate anything? That is the only arrow in your slim intellectual quiver.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 8, 2008 at 2:08 pm
If you support what the school board has done, contact your local board member and show your support. We cannot let this mob mentality get in the way of due process
Neal, Oklahoma City - Jan 8, 2008 at 11:06 am
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore Neal
Once again I will ask, why do you care and what business is it of yours? You can have Edmond along with the other xenophobes. As far as the race card, you brought up the issue with your silly affirmative action references.
T Scott, Oklahoma City - Jan 8, 2008 at 7:49 am
T Scott wrote: "Jason in Edmond, why do you care and what business is it of yours what goes on in OKC?"____T Scott, I see you don't quite grasp the concept of an internet forum. Let me sketch it out for you: a news article is posted, and folks, presumably, read it. Comments by those reading it are allowed on the website. Folks then add their commentary. It really is quite simple - do you need me to repeat it? T Scott wrote: "THE highest ranked school is Classen in OKC"____Putting aside the fact that Classen is a magnet school, what bearing does that have on the Edmond school system? T Scott wrote: "Edmond is no panacea. Suburban schools have their problems"_____I'll take Edmond North/Memorial/Santa Fe and their "problems" for my kids over any OKC school every day of the week.___As for the rest, it's the typical scummy bilge of those who love to play their precious race card as opposed to engaging in honest debate. Spew whatever silliness you want, but it's not gonna change this fact: this little tale appears to me to be a perfect example of affirmative action, and its corrosive effects on our institutions, at work.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 7, 2008 at 10:22 pm
Hush? I should hush? uh OK. Now I'll go back to typing. Jason in Edmond, why do you care and what business is it of yours what goes on in OKC? You say Edmond has some of the highest ranked schools in the state. THE highest ranked school is Classen in OKC. Edmond is no panacea. Suburban schools have their problems. What Edmond doesn't have as much as OKC is students that aren't lily white. C'mon Jason. That is the real reason you love Edmond isn't it?
T Scott, Oklahoma City - Jan 7, 2008 at 8:37 pm
Patricia, this man was stealing money from our children. In other words, taking resources away from a child's QUALITY EDUCATION! Misappropriation of activity funds? Contracts without competitive bidding? Reimbursement for his wife's airfare? Car reimbursement in addition to a car allowance? I think he got his hand caught in the cookie jar. If he were innocent, he should have met with the board way back in December. An individual with his level of education should know better.
Neal, Oklahoma City - Jan 7, 2008 at 6:11 pm
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore Neal
patricia wrote: "this will be my last comment to you". Promise? Heh. I'll say it again: this seems to me to be a prime example of affirmative action at work. Make of it whatever you want - but rest assured I won't miss a wink of sleep tonight worrying about it.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 7, 2008 at 5:36 pm
jason you are completly missing the entire point. i see you are only concerned with the fact that porter is a "black man". not concerned at all with the issue of education. this will be my last comment to you because i can see that ignorance plays a large role in your life. are you an expert on being a superintendant of public schools or on affirmative the good and the bad of it? in all things there are some good and some bad it is up to each of use to discern the difference for ourselves. but just because someones' idea (race) is not the same as yours does not make it wrong/right. race shouldnt come into play when it comes to education, only education should. as long as the "black man" stays in his so called place it is said he is doing "an excellent" job. but once he stands up for something or even makes a mistake it is simply because he is black?....get real man.
patricia, oklahoma city - Jan 7, 2008 at 5:31 pm
Heh, yeah Patricia - or should I say todd? - old Herb from Choctaw there's really got me on the ropes. I guess being an expert on the Edmond Public school system is a regular hobby out there in Choctaw - at least with one of its residents.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 7, 2008 at 5:22 pm
herb THANK YOU!!!!!!!
jason i see you cant do better than that.
patricia, oklahoma city - Jan 7, 2008 at 5:15 pm
t.scott you should just hush. the bottom line is the importance of the education of our children this man was trying to get that done and attempted to implement tools into this system that would enable the children in this system to get what they deserve out of education. wendi-i agree with you....bean please hush you sound really "foolish". as far as how good or bad the interior/exterior looks or doesnt look should not be as much of a concern as the "EDUCATION" being given to the students. how good your school looks dont mean squat if you werent taught how to read/write/equate etc. i am not saying that i am a supporter of or against porter. i am a supporter of "QUALITY EDUCATION" period. so to heck with how pretty a school is if even 1 child comes out of it lacking the basic skills to function in society. affirmative action shouldnt have been mentioned. when will society stop attempting to make all things a black or white issue. this is strictly an education issue. jason you surely could do better than that. i wouldnt care what color someone is or if they are male or female, if they are educating my child properly and continuing to do so i am all for them. and margaret thank you, i agree with you too .
patricia, oklahoma city - Jan 7, 2008 at 5:09 pm
Gee, Herb, I didn't know you were such an expert on the Edmond Public Schools. The truth of the matter is that Edmond has some of the highest ranked public schools in the state, and my children are getting an excellent education. As to the rest of your dribbling silliness, it is interesting to note that instead of offering a defense for Porter you ask a ridiculous rhetorical question. I'll say it again: this looks like to me a prime example of affirmative action at work. Make of it what you want.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 7, 2008 at 5:01 pm
Then Jason you should focus on the school system in Edmond because it is far from perfect. Do you have some other interest in the Oklahoma City school system or just Mr. Porter's ethnic background?
Herb, Choctaw - Jan 7, 2008 at 4:44 pm
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore Herb
Affirmative action at work again. And I notice that instead of simply defending himself with the facts, Porter imported an unruly, shrieking mob to try and make his case for him at the meeting. Thank goodness my children are in the Edmond school district.
Jason, Edmond - Jan 7, 2008 at 4:06 pm
If the purchase of the "Reading Program" really was not put out for bid then Mr. Porter broke state law. Is that OK to you Porter supporters?
Harry, Hangdown - Jan 7, 2008 at 3:06 pm
Wendi, I have been thinking about the movie "Stand By Me" during this whole mess. T Scott, I agree, many elementary schools in OKPS are great, but what about the high schools? We need some administrators in those schools with some backbone, not those who offer "harsh criticisms" when any changes are expected of them.
Margaret, Holdenville - Jan 7, 2008 at 1:16 pm
Am I the only one here who's seen the movie "Stand By Me?" Here it is, live in Oklahoma City. A school system in desperate need of repair FINALLY brings in a man who has hopes and dreams of making this a better system and because he needs to change a few things to do it suddenly he is a horrible person...Mr. Porter could have done great things in this school district...but because Oklahoma apparently is content with having some of the poorest educationial systems in the U.S. he will have to go somewhere where he can be appreciated. Way to go school board!!
wendi, wellston - Jan 7, 2008 at 1:11 pm
You could tell this was coming when two of Porter's major hires quit and went back to Memphis less than a month into their jobs. Hudson had nothing to do with the scathing reviews Porter received from district principals. Hudson has absolutely nothing to personally gain by serving on the board. Porter has had problems from day 1. Porter's allowing this to go public only made things worse. He had the opportunity to handle this privately and "went on vacation" with not even a phone call in the age of cell phones? Folks thats just plain dumb.
Jeffrey, Oklahoma City - Jan 7, 2008 at 1:11 pm

News Photo Galleriesview all