Foster parents say agency doesn't follow own rules
Foster parents say DHS doesn't follow own rules

Comments Comment on this article16

By Randy Ellis
Published: February 22, 2008

About 40 child advocates rallied at the state Capitol on Thursday to demand reforms to Oklahoma's child welfare system.

Advertisement

"Now is the time to act,” said J.T. Shearer, an Oklahoma foster care parent. "I believe the system is broken. It is our responsibility to fix it.”

Speakers said they were encouraged by a federal lawsuit filed last week seeking reforms in the state's foster care system.

A lot of regulations for a good foster care program are in place in Oklahoma — they just aren't followed, Shearer told The Oklahoman.

Oklahoma caseworkers are supposed to visit children in foster care homes at least once a month, and the agency claims to have better than 90 percent compliance with that regulation.

"That's their documentation,” Shearer scoffed. "I wouldn't trust anything in their documentation. I've seen their documentation.”

Shearer said 16 foster children have gone through his home in the past six years, and there are probably no more than two or three of those cases where the monthly visits actually occurred.

"One of my kids went almost three years without being visited by the primary caseworker,” he said.

It is a common practice among many caseworkers to just write down something similar to what was written the month before regarding a "visit” and to add a little information gathered through a telephone call, he said.

Shearer said he and his wife considered not speaking out, because of fear of retaliation, but decided it would probably be OK because "we have a great caseworker now who is very supportive and does everything by the book.”

DHS officials said in a news release last week that "because of high levels of monitoring and self-reporting, OKDHS is able to document whether or not an incident involving child safety may be present.”

Problems vary by county
Lana Freeman, executive vice president of the Foster Care Association of Oklahoma, a parent group, said whether monthly in-home visits are done seems to vary a great deal from county to county and caseworker to caseworker.

Freeman said it's not a problem in McClain County, where she is, but she has heard a lot of complaints from Oklahoma County and other counties where caseworkers have extremely high case loads.

"There is a desperate need for more foster parents,” she said.

It's hard to recruit them because the state only pays $365 to $498 a month, depending on the child's age, and that isn't enough to cover the costs of raising a kid, she said.

Foster parents also often complain about a lack of support from DHS — both in dealing with emergency situations and in dealing with common issues, such as finding eligible doctors and dentists, Freeman said.

More die than in war
Another speaker, Kathie Briggs, said there are more U.S. children killed by child abuse and neglect each year than U.S. soldiers killed in Iraq.

The U.S. lost 849 soldiers in Iraq in 2004. That same year, 1,490 children died from abuse or neglect, she said. In 2005, there were 846 soldiers killed in Iraq, while 1,460 children died from abuse or neglect.

Briggs said the numbers are dear to her heart since she has a son who fought in Iraq and her 2-year-old granddaughter, Kelsey, died from abuse.

Kelsey became the poster child for what is wrong with Oklahoma's system when she died from child abuse in 2005.

While under supervision of a judge and DHS, Kelsey continued to suffer broken bones and bruises.

Her mother, Raye Dawn Smith, and stepfather, Michael Lee Porter, are in prison.

Public outrage over the death of Kelsey and other children has prompted several changes to state law. More needs to be done, Briggs said.


 


Toolbar sponsored by: David Stanley Ford

Apartments in Oklahoma City
Apartment Listings in Oklahoma City. Floorplans, Amenities & Pricing.
Apartments.com/OklahomaCity

Get Sarah Palin's Look
The best lenses have no glare, are smudge free and scratch resistant.
www.Crizal.com

shareView All

Buzz Up!


Leave a Comment

Something to say about this topic? Submit a Letter to the Editor online

Thank you for joining our conversations on newsok. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.


Log in below or sign up (it's free).





What is this Federal Law of Color? The FBI doesn't make laws, they investigate. What I have gotten out of this discussion is people are complainging because kids have been picked up who shouldn't have been or they should have been & were not or somebody says they were returned by a judge when they shouldn't have been. It seems to me, we may need to change laws & put prevention practices in place to help parents & give more & better training for social workers & lighten their case loads so they can concentrate with a micromanagement lens on each case. As for judges, are we not supposed to trust their judgement? I thought that is the way the court system is set up.
Southern, Oklahoma City - Mar 1, 2008 at 2:18 pm
In reading the many articles and comments about OKDHS violations and shortcomings, it occurs to me that what we are dealing with here is federal violation of Color of Law. Go to the (FBI) Federal Bureau of Investigation web site and read up on this. Oklahoma laws and policies are intact regarding the procedures of Child Welfare. All these conflicts are due to OKDHS admin, managers, caseworkers and employees by ignoring or going outside of these laws and polices. They justify this by saying they are understaffed and uderpaid. There is no justification for breaking Federal or Oklahoma laws. More on this later.
ge-mo, Oklahoma City - Mar 1, 2008 at 6:31 am
I have been a foster parent in Canadian County for the last 5 years. We as foster parent are there to take care of the children in DHS custody. We are made to fill like the criminal . When you do fight for the childrens right yes there is retaliations. We are threaten by having the children removed form our home even our own biological children. There is only one foster care worker one judge in our county that is over all of these cases. The foster care worker and the caseworkers that we have delt nothing but lies are told to foster parents. When someone is thinking about foster care parent i have to tell them about my story and how it almost ruined my life and my childrens life. Not until being involved in foster care i never had to hire a lawyer for be in a court room. Please thinks twice about this. It's not the kids in the system that are the problem. It's the imoral DHS system and caseworkers
kasi, mustang - Feb 28, 2008 at 12:56 pm
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore kasi
So Oleana, did you turn in a referral? If you didn't do what she told you to do to get the process started, you really didn't do your part!
Southern, Oklahoma City - Feb 28, 2008 at 10:58 am
Those who have not had any involvement with DHS will not understand the trouble and the problems that those of us that have been or are involved with DHS. I as a single mom have been dealing with DHS for more than 4yrs. And to this day I can't get over the what an old caseworker said to me when I presented her physical evidence of abuse. I was informed that she was not a investigator and I would have to call in a referall, even though here I was presenting her with photos, names of county officers who taken photos and made reports. But yet nothing was done. I do not understand how a Childwelfare worker can just turn her head and dismiss evidence of abuse. Isn't her job to start an investigation when present with reports and photos of abuse. And how can DHS say they are for keeping siblings together. My two sons and two daughters have had no visits scheduled in over 1 1/2 years, but yet up til this month there were three siblings in DHS foster and kinship foster care. Isn't the caseworker over the case that is responsible for those visits, but yet siblings are being forced apart for what purpose. Does DHS not care how it affects siblings?
Oleana, centrahoma - Feb 26, 2008 at 10:58 am
The problems are the same as when I was a CWS worker 1997-1998. Nothing changes unless the root cause is dealt with. Brothers & sisters, the cancer of inept management has metastasized. Bad managers are promoting other bad managers who will not expose the ineptitude and the magnitude of the profoundly idiotic management in DHS. Until this is dealt with nothing, no amount of money can change the outcomes.
M, Truth - Feb 25, 2008 at 8:32 am
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore M
How can a caseworker know what is going on with a child if they only, check on them once a month? They need a baby cam to monitor the kids...
Candace, Lakeland - Feb 23, 2008 at 6:11 pm
As you can see there is still bitterness between the families of Kelsey. For the record Spc. Lance Briggs was not in rehab in Georgia. He did make a stop there to process out of the Army on his way back from Iraq. It was not proven that Kelsey's legs were broken in court. The defense attorney did make a good effort in confusing Dr. Andy Sullivan a specialist from the OU Medical Center. DA Richard Smothermon has a home in Shawnee and is in the process of building a new home in Pott. Co. as soon as his son graduates this year from High School. It has never been proven that Mike Porter was the one that killed Kelsey. Yes, he did make a plea agreement at his request. As you can see there are several slanderous statements made here by Mr. Fowler. None of his statement has anything to do with this article. I apologize to the readers that have been subjected to this. Please pray for both families.
kathie - Feb 23, 2008 at 12:19 am
Kathy Briggs son was in rehab in Georgia not in Iraq.Kathy should have been arrested, it was proved in court that Kelsey was in her care when her legs were broken.The illegal DA RICHARD SMOTHERMON that does not live in district 23,he lives in Edmond ,OK.on GREY FOX RUN STREET,RICRDARD SMOTHERMON and KATHY BRIGGS cut a deal with the one that killed Kelsey,to frame Raye Dawn.
Darrell, Meeker - Feb 22, 2008 at 8:33 pm
That is my point exactly. Our soldiers are in danger 24/7. It sickens me to know we have lost so many soldiers. The differnce is, like my son who signed up for this, he was armed, and he was trained. They know upfront there is danger at every turn. Many times the children abused or killed are in their own homes with a parent or caregiver. There is an obvious difference between the soldier fatalities and the children. Either way the numbers are astounding and that is the intent of the comparison.
kathie - Feb 22, 2008 at 2:45 pm
Tim, I understand your point, BUT, those soldiers are in a high-risk situation, and the children shouldn't be. The comparision is okay with me because the children's deaths are preventable. Unfortunately, the soldiers' deaths aren't during war time.
Allison, Noble - Feb 22, 2008 at 1:57 pm
The numbers are not meant to be compared to children only in foster care. The issue of child abuse pertains to all children, not just the ones in DHS custody. DHS cannot and should not be blamed for children they were not responsible. However: regardless of who is responsible children are dying and we should all care. Children should not be dying at this alarming rate in a country like ours. The numbers posted were meant to get the attention of the readers to let them know just how large the number of deaths is. Apparently it did get some attention. And I hope people will now realize this subject needs more attention. I will say if anyone of the average of 50 children killed in our state was a member of your family you would understand the comparison.
kathie - Feb 22, 2008 at 1:53 pm
I think an average of 50 children in OK each year, plus the fact that we lead the nation in deaths currently are enough to get my attention. At what point is this not just DHS's problem and OUR problem (as citizens)for allowing this to continue?
R, Tulsa - Feb 22, 2008 at 10:01 am
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore R
David, I'm not denying that. I don't care what the point of the article is. I think they are skewing the numbers by comparing it to the number of soldiers killed in Iraq. I agree that something needs to be done to keep children from dying. But how about they list the number of kids in foster care and then compare the number of kids who are dying while in foster care. That was give us more accurate assessment of how bad the problem is.
Tim, Yukon - Feb 22, 2008 at 9:57 am
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore Tim
Tim, I think the point is that children are dying. Losing one is too many!
David, Enid - Feb 22, 2008 at 9:14 am
There are a lot more children in the U.S. than there are soldiers fighting in Iraq. I think they are trying to compare apples to oranges when comparing the number of children who died from abuse to the number of soldiers who died in Iraq.
Tim, Yukon - Feb 22, 2008 at 8:20 am
Report as inappropriate or
Ignore Tim

    News Photo Galleriesview all