Secrecy move stirs discord

 
By Nolan Clay | Published: March 15, 2008    Comment on this article Leave a comment

Oklahoma Supreme Court Justice Marian Opala criticized fellow justices Friday, calling new secrecy rules on court records ill-conceived, censorship and shocking.

More Info


How records fight mistaken identity
Terry L. Nichols got a $20 traffic ticket in Tulsa County in 2005.

No, it wasn't the Nichols who helped build the Oklahoma City bomb. It was a different guy, who, according to court records, was born in the same year but on a different date.

Richard Nixon has a protection order against him in Oklahoma County. No, it's not the dead former president. The Nixon with the order against him is much younger, according to court records.

Those are two examples of how details in court records are important to verifying identity.

Journalists consider birth dates from court records key information to assure accuracy in their work. So do private investigators, lawyers and law enforcement officers.

Businesses use the personal information in court records to screen potential employees. And those into the dating scene check out potential suitors before the first kisses.

That all could change once new Supreme Court rules go into effect barring certain personal information such as birth dates from court records.

Advertisement

"How can you keep public records from public knowledge?” he said from a national meeting in Tucson, Ariz.

"I don't understand how anybody who is a lawyer can say that a government can ration, censor or screen public records from the public. There's just no way.”

Opala is known as a champion of the rights found in the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. A First Amendment award is named for him. He said "the First Amendment does not allow public information to be screened or rationed.”

"You cannot ration public information. It has to flow, and nobody can stop it,” he said.

Justices have faced widespread criticism this week over the new policy.

Justices ordered the removal of court documents from the Internet. They also ruled that court documents filed at the courthouse in the future cannot have certain personal information such as birth dates.

Page 1 of 2



Related Topics: Judiciary, Crime and Law



Leave a Comment

Thank you for joining our conversation on NewsOK.com. We encourage your discussion but ask that you stay within the bounds of our commenting and posting policy. Please help by flagging comments that violate these guidelines. Posts that contain obscene or vulgar language will be immediately flagged and not posted.

If you prefer your thoughts to appear in The Oklahoman, we encourage you to submit a letter to the editor.

Would you like to leave a comment?

Log in or sign up (it's free).

comments powered by Disqus


Need A Loan?
Have Bad Credit? We can help you get a loan. Let us show you how.
www.bestconsumerresearch.com
Best Money Market Rates
Browse Top 25 Money Market Rates. Sort by APY,Reviews, Banks.
www.Bankaholic.com

News Photo Galleriesview all