Don't sell water to Texas, speakers urge

By Tony Thornton
Published: April 2, 2008

More than a dozen speakers, including two Texans, called on legislators and the governor today to resist any desires to sell Oklahoma water to Texas.

Advertisement

One water activist from southeast Oklahoma suggested that Attorney General Drew Edmondson isn't vigorously defending the state's interests in a federal lawsuit aimed at obtaining 100 billions of gallons a year from Oklahoma.

An appeals court hearing on the lawsuit is scheduled next month in Denver, and a Texas water district has hired "top guns" to win the case, said Charlette Hearn of the Southern Oklahoma Water Alliance.

She questioned why Edmondson hasn't hired outside attorneys for the Tarrant Regional Water District's lawsuit.

"The time is nigh. It's not any time for the attorney general to fumble, because we are watching," said Hearne, of Broken Bow.

Edmondson's spokesman, Charlie Price, said the office is vigorously defending the lawsuit.

"The attorney general is convinced that our attorneys are doing all that can be done," Price said.

State Rep. Jerry Ellis said such lawsuits have become commonplace in the drought-stricken southeast United States.

"Now it's Oklahoma's turn," said Ellis, D-Valliant.

Tarrant Regional is one of two north Texas water districts that applied for permits for Oklahoma's water last year. Both proposed to buy it, and Tarrant Regional subsequently filed the lawsuit.

Both districts seek water from southeast Oklahoma tributaries before it reaches the Red River, where it becomes too salty to drink without expensive treatment.

Most of the ire raised at today's news conference was aimed at the Tarrant district.

While the water district's leaders say they want to pay Oklahoma a fair price, Ellis said that's a joke.

"They're trying to lock in a price now so they won't have to renegotiate in 50 years, when water is crucial," he said.

It wasn't clear whether any recent development other than the pending court hearing prompted the news conference. Ellis said he's unaware of any effort by legislators or Gov. Brad Henry to negotiate a sale. There could be a strong lobbying effort afoot, however, he said.

Toolbar sponsored by: David Stanley Ford
Bookmark and Share





Comments

Leave a comment. Log in below or sign up (it's free).

   
All of these comments are interesting but very inaccurate and uninformed. None of the opiners has a dog in this hunt nor does Ms. Hearne or Jerry Ellis. I would any interested person learn the facts.
Joe, Hugo - Aug 12, 2008 5:41 AM
Report: Offensive language
And if allowed to come across state line to purchase that water, what is next ? Can they sue to force discharges from upstream dams to make water available ? Or extend the pipelines on further north to Oklahoma lakes. Lakes that we already have serious water fluctuations. I don't think its wise to let them get their foot in the door and set a legal precedent that we will be powerless to stop in the future. Make them go to their lakes, such as Lake Fork, Toledo Bend, etc. They have plenty of water, but they want ours because they can get it cheaper.
Lynn, Oklahoma City - Apr 2, 2008 5:28 PM
Report: Offensive language
Once water is sold to Texas they have the 1st right of refusl for perpetuity. This has been litigated countless times and it is always ruled on in this manner. In other words, once we sell it to Texas, we cannot ever get it back regardless of how desperate we might be for this resource. Even if it stipulates Oklahoma has the right of 1st refusal in the contract Texas can and file suit and win.
dj, guthrie - Apr 2, 2008 4:27 PM
Report: Offensive language
Francis, Edmond - I hope our attorneys can read better than you and Floyd of Purtle. The issue is not selling them water, nor the amount of money nor what that could be used for. The issue is getting locked into a 50 year non-negotiable contract. And poor Floyd, the water is not coming out of the Red River. Once it gets to that point...not ours anymore. However, that would be a novel idea, selling Texas water that isn't ours.
Charles, Oklahoma City - Apr 2, 2008 4:10 PM
Report: Offensive language
Francis is correct. And, If Texas wins the case, they get the water FOR FREE. Thats right folks, FREE. OK will lose any opportunity to negotiate any price for that water.
Jeffrey, Oklahoma City - Apr 2, 2008 4:06 PM
Report: Offensive language
This is just the tip of the iceberg. Access to fresh water is going to be the biggest conflict of the 21st century, and Oklahoma needs to hold fast to its own resources. Quarrying is already having a detrimental effect on the Arbuckle-Simpson aquifer in southeast Oklahoma, and the average flow of the Blue River has dropped substantially over the past decade. If Texas can't sustain its own growth, it needs to come up with a better plan. Mark my words: if we sell our water now, we will live to regret it.
Maria - Apr 2, 2008 4:05 PM
Report: Offensive language
Resist selling water that eventually leaves our state and becomes effectively useless to us and North Texas. Yeah, that's backwards a** thinking if I have ever heard it. What the hell is wrong with these people? Do they not think that the money couldn't be used in their districts for improvement projects, like bridges? Hmmmm, there's an idea, and a way to pay for some of our crumbling infrastructure. Get a clue people, make the money, and use it wisely.
Francis, Edmond - Apr 2, 2008 3:55 PM
Report: Offensive language
No sell. Texas has water. They do not want to build the pipelines it would take to get it to Tarrent County due to the cost. If OK does sell then OK should have a strict contract that is renegotiated every year.
Tom, Edmond - Apr 2, 2008 3:24 PM
Report: Offensive language
What a bunch of morons we have...Tarrant Water District wants to buy water from the Red River. That's basically it. Sell it on our terms or one of two things will happen. It will continue flowing unimpeded to the Gulf or the court will dictate the terms. Perhaps it's that even our AG has more than just chicken poop upstairs and can see the stupidity in Oklahoma's refusal to sell.
Floyd R, Purtle - Apr 2, 2008 3:11 PM
Report: Offensive language
What has Texas ever done for oklahoma? As far as I'm concerned they can all drink salt water....
Herron, Blanchard - Apr 2, 2008 2:53 PM
Report: Offensive language
Yeah! Screw them Texans!!! Let em die of thirst!
JJ, oklahoma city - Apr 2, 2008 2:45 PM
Report: Offensive language