McAlester district attorney ordered police inquiry into online comments about him
McAlester district attorney ordered police inquiry into online comments about him
By Tony Thornton
Comments 
4
Published: August 15, 2008
McALESTER — District Attorney Jim Miller was so outraged by what people wrote about him on a local message board that he filed a police complaint.
Multimedia
More Info
Jim Miller
Who authorized the subpoena?
Miller said he provided police with comment threads on the site about him from 10 dates since October 2007.
That prompted two McAlester police detectives to show up at McCooler administrator Harold King's door Tuesday. They delivered a subpoena requiring King to produce identifying information about 35 people who posted under pseudonyms on the site.
King filed a formal objection Thursday, saying he won't comply because the subpoena doesn't indicate on whose authority it was issued.
A legal expert told The Oklahoman that only a judge or a prosecutor can authorize such a subpoena. Miller said he didn't authorize it; he simply filed a police complaint "like any other citizen.”
‘Smacks of intimidation'
Whether Miller formally authorized the subpoena or not, it "smacks of intimidation,” said Joey Senat, past president of Freedom of Information Oklahoma and an associate professor of journalism at Oklahoma State University.
"It's anti-democratic. In other words, our government officials should expect to be criticized. ... To threaten someone with any sort of crime for doing that is nothing short of unacceptable,” Senat said.
He said if Miller thinks he has been libeled on the Web site, he should file a civil lawsuit.
About Oklahoma's libel laws
Oklahoma is among 16 states with criminal libel laws still on the books, according to the Student Press Law Center. Most recently, Utah abolished its law in 2007.
Oklahoma's libel law was last changed by legislators in 1895, according to a textbook by Senat, "Mass Communication Law in Oklahoma.” The law prohibits false written speech that exposes someone to hatred, contempt or ridicule.
Former state Sen. Gene Stipe, a frequent target of King's Web site, filed a criminal libel complaint against King in 2005. Miller's predecessor declined to file charges.
At that time, an official with the state agency that represents district attorneys said he'd never heard of a criminal libel report being filed with police, much less filed as a charge by a prosecutor.
Related Topics:
Law, Criminal Law
Prev
Something to say about this topic? Submit a Letter to the Editor online
Thank you for joining our conversations on newsok. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.
Log in below or sign up (it's free).