Pile on corned beef, start a Reuben tradition

by Dave Cathey Modified: March 17, 2009 at 10:41 am •  Published: March 11, 2009
How in the one month when corned beef is king can we make the sandwich of the month anything other than the Reuben?

We can’t.

If you’re roasting corned beef, you’re bound to have leftovers. Simply pile it high on pumpernickel bread spread with Thousand Island or Russian dressing, combine with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut before putting on the griddle and toasting until the cheese is bubbly. Lunch is set for the week.

In this related story, local chef Sean Cummings says corned beef is not eaten in Ireland on St. Patrick’s Day, or any other. And he should know; that’s his heritage.

However, the tradition of eating corned beef on St. Pat’s Day does come from the Irish — those who lived in New York City.

Unable to find their beloved Irish bacon, the New Yorkers borrowed more affordable corned beef as a substitute from their Jewish neighbors.

Of course, St. Pat himself was more known for blue than green, but that’s a whole other story. Authenticity can be overrated; corned beef is not.

Especially if it is cured in a 24-day process in a brine of your own making. No, I don’t do that, but Kurt Fleischfresser and his chef apprentices at The Coach House do.

by Dave Cathey
Food Editor
The Oklahoman's food editor, Dave Cathey, keeps his eye on culinary arts and serves up news and reviews from Oklahoma’s booming food scene.
+ show more

13 places to find a Reuben Sandwich
→Beatnix Cafe, 136 NW 13.

→Bison Witches, 211 E Main, Norman

→The Coach House, 6437 Avondale Drive.

→Ingrid’s Kitchen, 3701 N Youngs.

→Hobby’s Hoagies, 222 S Santa Fe Ave., Edmond; 325 N Walker.

→Jersey Mike’s, 1940 S Air Depot; 7500 S Santa Fe; 1630 NW 23; 2522 W Memorial.

→Kilkenny’s Irish Pub and Eatery, 1413 E 15th St., Tulsa.

→Lottinvilles Wood Grill, 801 Signal Ridge, Edmond.

→Manhattan Pasta, Pizza and Grill, 17200 N May.

→Markie’s Cafe, 612 N Robinson.

→Shartel Cafe, 5116 N Shartel.

→VZD’s, 4200 N Western.

→Which Wich, 215 W Boyd, Norman.

Got a favorite Reuben sandwich?
E-mail dcathey@opubco.com or send a reply on Twitter by following @TheFoodDood.

Trending Now


  1. 1
    High school football: Sperry rallies for win week after lineman dies
  2. 2
    New video shows beheading of British aid worker David Haines by Islamic State group
  3. 3
    OU football: Jordan Phillips breaks out 'Shmoney dance' after sack against Tennessee
  4. 4
    VIDEO: Oklahoma State WR Brandon Sheperd catches 18-yard touchdown from Daxx Garman
  5. 5
    OSU football: J.W. Walsh watches first quarter of OSU-UTSA from the top of Boone Pickens Stadium
+ show more