Share “Point me to Oklahoma's premier pizza pie”

Point me to Oklahoma's premier pizza pie

by Dave Cathey Modified: March 18, 2009 at 10:43 am •  Published: March 18, 2009
Most people love pizza, but I’ve always been a touch contrarian.

I’ve always bristled at the notion that pizza was worth any kind of long-term devotion. Growing up, I would eat a burrito filled with vegetable protein and processed green chili from U-Totem before setting foot in Godfather’s, Conans Pizza or Mr. Gatti’s Pizza.

People told me it’s just because I never had any good pizza. Perhaps.

I’ve eaten at Chicago’s Pizzeria Uno. I enjoyed it but didn’t understand why folks were waiting up to two hours to get it. I would eat it again, gladly, but the allegiance I still don’t get. It was like a taco salad filled with rich tomato sauce, cheese and sausage — and that’s not a criticism.

I’ve never been to New York, but I’ve had my share of New York-style pizza.

When I moved to Oklahoma, the pizza landscape was about as sparse as the places I’d lived before, dominated by chains. That was in 1988.

That landscape has changed in two decades, but my apathy toward pizza remains.

Don’t get me wrong, I don’t hate it. In fact, some of it I like very much. But I’m settling into middle age and fear that my contrarianism could develop into full-fledged crankiness if I’m not careful.

It’s time to embrace pizza, so help me out.

I’m aware of The Hideaway, Falcone’s, Perri’s, Sophabella’s, Joey’s Pizzeria, Pepperoni Grill, Italiano’s, The Wedge, Sauced, Saturn Grill, Papa Angelo’s in Bethany, Italian Jim’s and Luigiano’s in Yukon, and Jo’s and Rodney’s of Purcell. Point me to the best spots; I’ll check them out and share the results.

by Dave Cathey
Food Editor
The Oklahoman's food editor, Dave Cathey, keeps his eye on culinary arts and serves up news and reviews from Oklahoma’s booming food scene.
+ show more

Pizza, please
→E-mail pizza preferences to

→For more pizza talk:

→Follow TheFoodDood on Twitter; join the chat at #okpizza.


  1. 1
    Adrian Peterson reports to Vikings camp: 'I'm a part of this football team'
  2. 2
    One industry expert offers his plan to help country radio: Fewer songs by women
  3. 3
    Run Warren Run Folds As Elizabeth Warren Spurns White House Bid
  4. 4
    Europe plots to stage an 'alternative World Cup' in place of Russia 2018
  5. 5
    Two More Texas Flood Victims Identified, Including Mom Washed Away in House
+ show more