Thwarting reform does nothing to benefit Oklahoma students
Oklahoma took one step forward and one backward last week.
Moving forward, Gov. Mary Fallin approved rules implementing an A-F grading system for schools. Falling back, a state House committee disapproved those same agency rules to thwart reform.
NewsOK Related Articles
Until this year, schools were given an Academic Performance Index score ranging from 0 to 1,500. The problem with API is that few people know it exists or what it means. Is a high score best? Or is it like your golf game where the lower the number, the better? The ineffectiveness of the API system is apparent by the fact that virtually no parent knows the score given a child's school.
On the other hand, everyone understands the difference between an A and an F. This is apparently what worries some in the education establishment.
Opponents claim good schools will be punished, but an estimated 60 percent will get an A or B and only 2 percent an F. That's hardly punitive.
The goal isn't to embarrass, but to incentivize improvement, which is what has happened in other states that grade schools. Furthermore, killing the A-F system jeopardizes Oklahoma's waiver from the federal No Child Left Behind law.