A former pharmacist convicted of murder complained Monday in an appeal that he did not get a fair trial because his lead attorney botched his defense.
Jerome Jay Ersland, 60, is serving a life term in prison.
“There is no doubt that this was ineffective assistance of counsel, probably the most egregious example of it that we have ever seen,” said a major Ersland supporter, state Sen. Ralph Shortey, R-Oklahoma City.
The former lead attorney, Irven Box, said he and the three other attorneys involved in the 2011 trial did their best with a difficult client.
“There's not one thing we would have done different in defending him,” Box said.
An Oklahoma County jury found Ersland guilty of first-degree murder for fatally shooting a wounded robber inside an Oklahoma City pharmacy in 2009. Jurors rejected his claim that he was defending himself and two female employees.
His new attorney filed a 26-page brief Monday asking the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals to overturn that murder conviction.
The new attorney, Doug Friesen, accuses Box of a series of failures in the handing of the case.
“I am simply saying, under these sets of facts, I do not believe Jerome got a fair trial,” Friesen said at a news conference.
Friesen wrote in the brief, “Here, trial counsel's ineffectiveness began as a belief that he could not lose this case and devolved into his failure to thoroughly investigate the facts and circumstances underlying” Ersland's criminal charge.
A key issue in the appeal is whether Box told his client District Attorney David Prater had been willing to possibly work out something along the lines of a manslaughter plea deal.
In an affidavit signed last week, Ersland wrote: “Irven Box never conveyed to me there was a possibility of anything other than trial.”
Box disputed that Monday, saying he twice told his client prosecutors had talked of negotiating to a sentence of “double-digit” years. Box said Ersland wasn't interested in a plea that included a felony conviction because he wanted to keep his pharmacy license.