DVD review: 'Film Noir Classic Collection Vol. 5'


Posted July 23, 2010 by Gene Triplett Comment on this article Leave a comment
A movie doesn’t automatically qualify as classic film noir just because it has cops and robbers, ruthless femme fatales, a lot of night scenes and was shot in black and white between 1940 and 1960.

With Volume 5 of “The Film Noir Classic Collection,” Warner Home Video seems to be scraping the bottom of the B-movie bin, at least in the case of three of the eight films offered in this boxed set.

For example, “Crime in the Streets” (1956) is a low-budget, second-rate “Blackboard Jungle,” trying to cash in on the juvenile delinquent craze of the day with John Cassavetes making his inauspicious screen debut as an angry, alienated teen. Considering its over-the-top melodramatics and a Hollywood ending that can be seen 10 slum blocks away, it’s surprising that it was written by Reginald Rose (“12 Angry Men”) and directed by Don Siegel (“Dirty Harry,” “The Shootist”), whose other works were usually top-shelf.

Phil Karlson’s “The Fenix City Story” (1955), a fact-based tale of corruption and murder in small-town Alabama, plays out like a lurid (for its time) semidocumentary, with real Southern citizens giving gawdawful performances alongside a respectable professional cast including John McIntire, Richard Kiley and Edward Andrews, who try but fail to elevate the quality of this forgettable, preachy programmer.

And Vincent Sherman’s “Backfire” (1950) is an aptly-titled  dud with miscast Gordon MacRae as a man desperate to prove his pal (Edmond O’Brien) is innocent of murder.

Page 1 of 2




If you prefer your thoughts to appear in The Oklahoman's Opinion section, we encourage you to submit a letter to the editor.

Smiley face
ENTERTAINMENT EDITOR
 |   | 

Gene Triplett is a University of Central Oklahoma journalism graduate with 36 years experience as a newspaper writer and editor. As a reporter...


Advertisement