Share “A Comparison of Tile Backer Boards”

A Comparison of Tile Backer Boards

Published on NewsOK Published: December 23, 2012

Earlier this month, I got started with another shower tile renovation for one of my Denver tile contracting clients.  In this particular case the shower tile was still intact, which is a rarity considering the tile was set on green board. I think one of the reasons it had still survived was it was relatively new as this house was only built in 1996.  Back in the older days, green board was widely used as a tile substrate. People would be making a big mistake to use it now. (It was banned from use for “wet areas” with the 2006 IRC building code.) What was more surprising was that cement based backer boards were available when this home was built and this green board use reflects a cost-cutting measure that is usually a mistake.

The right backer board for wet or dry areas

Tile can be set just about any where, floors and walls are the most common. As a tile contractor, I have even installed some on ceilings.  The main consideration for backer choice lies in the location of the tile. Backsplashes and some tile wainscot can be set on regular drywall (or fiberglass versions of drywall). Water and gypsum based backers = mush in my book.  It seems that building officials now agree.  An added bonus to cement board use is its resistance to mold growth…that old green board was still paper based and mold loves to eat paper.

Types of cement backer board

Permabase is National Gypsum’s product and it is very much like WonderBoard from Custom Building Products. Both of these boards are a cement and aggregate core with a fiberglass mesh “skin”. Durock from USG is a slightly lighter weight version of comparable construction methods. 

HardieBacker – My favorite backer board

The other main type is what I call the “Hardie” type.  As you may have guessed, HardieBacker is a non-aggregate based product from James Hardie.  The same people who make a HardiePlank siding. Custom Building Products has their version of this, called Rhino board, but they limit it to ¼” thick and recommend it for floors and countertop installations.

Backer board by the numbers

Cost, strength, and weight will vary from product to product.  In my area the cost of a 3 x 5 foot ½ inch thick sheet of any of these products runs about $11.  The ¼” thick versions are usually about a dollar cheaper. Weights range from 2.4 pounds / sq ft to 3.0 pounds / sq ft for the ½” thick stock. That relates to 36 pounds for the lighter weight Durock and 45 pounds for the WonderBoard. 

Continue reading this story on the... has disabled the comments for this article.