Share “Column: Don't jump to conclusions on...”

Column: Don't jump to conclusions on Pistorius

Published on NewsOK Modified: February 15, 2013 at 3:22 pm •  Published: February 15, 2013
Advertisement

In sport, Oscar Pistorius demonstrated how easy it is to be wrong about people. An athlete with prosthetic limbs competing at the Olympic Games? No way!

That lesson — don't leap to hasty, ill-informed conclusions — is worth remembering now as the double-amputee Olympian stands charged with murder in the shooting of his girlfriend.

Her life is gone. Anyone who declares that his life, for all intents and purposes, is now over, too, had better be 1000 percent sure of themselves. The question "What happened?" is, of course, natural. It was on all our lips. But the response cannot be found by pouring through old interviews Pistorius gave or from his now silent Twitter account. This is a murder investigation, not a guessing game. Serious stuff that needs to be treated as such.

At times like these, when a public figure we perhaps liked and admired is accused of things that are abhorrent, we want answers and we want them immediately.

We want to know not only the facts but what they mean, for us and the wider world. The first reaction is often shock. Then the questions: Does this mean we should also toss out everything we thought we knew about this person? If they were wrong'uns, was it also wrong to cheer for them, take pleasure in what they did and even be inspired by it?

In short, when our stars fall off the pedestals we build for them, we want to know not only whether we should burn their biographies, wristbands and commemorative T-shirts but also erase from our minds absolutely everything they said, did and supposedly stood for.

At the most basic level, one idea Pistorius promoted with his running was that facts speak for themselves.

Fact: A man whose lower legs were amputated when he was 11 months old can compete at the Olympics.

Fact: Pistorius changed attitudes when he made history at the London Games.

Fact: With each click-click-click of his prosthetic limbs on the track, he proved how wrong we can be when we make assumptions about people, when we try to guess what they are and aren't capable of.

Those are valuable lessons, especially now, when the lack of complete facts and pressure of so many questions can quickly lead to bum conclusions and answers.

Certainly, if Pistorius is found guilty of murdering Reeva Steenkamp, the lessons from London will not survive. Everything he achieved on the track would be rendered secondary. Police said Steenkamp was shot four times in Pistorius' villa Thursday. Prosecutor Gerrie Nel said in court he would pursue a charge of premeditated murder.

Continue reading this story on the...