Berry Tramel, Sports columnist

Read more columns by Berry Tramel. Or visit Berry's blog

Contact Berry -- E-mail: btramel@opubco.com. Phone: (405) 475-3313.

Brave Moccasins make trip to Norman despite clear mismatch

By Berry Tramel
Published: August 30, 2008

NORMAN — The last time a lower-division team dared tread on Owen Field, nobody knew much about Indiana State except this: Larry Bird went there.

Advertisement

Now come the Chattanooga Mocs, known as the Tennessee-Chattanooga Moccasins when their basketball team played Billy Tubbs' epic 1988 Sooners in the NCAA Tournament. And again, this team is known for an alum.

Terrell Owens. "TO went there,” said OU flanker Quentin Chaney. "That's one thing we all know.”

There's something else we all know. This is going to be a non-competitive football game. This is the biggest mismatch in modern OU history.

Where is the adult supervision? What kind of a system produces this kind of a game?

Please don't take this as criticism of Chattanooga. The Mocs should be saluted for taking on the challenge and providing an opponent at all. OU athletic director Joe Castiglione said this week that if Chattanooga hadn't agreed to play, the Sooners might not have found a foe for this season opener. It was getting that desperate.

But this is nowhere close to a fair fight, and not just because of the scholarship differences (OU can give out 85, Chattanooga 65).

Can't really say about the dusty days when Bennie Owen's Sooners would hang a hundred on Kingfisher College or Central Normal. But since World War II, there has not been an OU game matching teams with such a talent gulf.

Larry Bird's alma mater wasn't very good in 1999, a mediocre Division I-AA program, but Indiana State went against Bob Stoops' first OU squad, which was offensively scary but not close to the overall powerhouse the Sooners are today.

These Sooners are loaded with playmakers, veterans and potential NFL talent. Meanwhile, Chattanooga is the Baylor of the lower division. Chattanooga plays in one of the best I-AA conferences but hasn't had a winning conference record since 1991. Chattanooga's best overall record in the last 25 years is 7-4. The Mocs have stepped up to play an occasional major-conference opponent, including Arkansas last season, but in four games against Memphis this decade, Chattanooga's average defeat is 47-15.

This matchup is so bad, the television networks passed, and you all know by how rarely TV skips an OU game.

Empowered by Appalachian State's monumental upset of Michigan last season, the Sooners this week embraced the any-given-Saturday theme.

"A football team's a football team,” said OU o-lineman Trent Williams. "Anybody can beat anybody.”

Maybe that's true with teams from the same universe. But U.S. Grant can't beat Tulsa Union. The Tulsa 66ers can't beat the Celtics. The Woonsocket Sentinels can't beat the Dallas Cowboys. And Chattanooga can't beat Oklahoma.

So how did this game come to be?

College football non-conference scheduling has grown increasingly squishier in the last decade. The reasons are many:

* Bowls. The proliferation of bowls has produced many tie-ins with the major conferences, so schools know if they can just get to six victories, they will make a bowl game. Thus schools schedule to win rather than to compete.

* Coaches. The big contracts make coaches protective of their jobs, so padding a record increases job security.

* Money. Playing more home games has been a priority for many schools trying to make a budget. Many major-conference teams play seven home games; a few play eight.

All of the above has created a supply-and-demand problem. Not enough mid-majors to soften the schedule of major-conference teams, so schools are going further down the food chain. Hence OU gets all the way down to Chattanooga.

After an agreement to host Middle Tennessee fell through, Castiglione said, "We were calling everybody . Biggest response was ‘no.' A resounding no. They simply didn't want to play the University of Oklahoma in Norman.”

But Chattanooga was willing, so tonight at Owen Field, we have a mismatch for the ages. A sellout crowd will wildly cheer it, the media will breathlessly report it and coaches will studiously analyze it, as if it was a championship game and not an exhibition game.

Who's to blame for this historic mismatch? Start with us all.


Toolbar sponsored by: David Stanley Ford
Bookmark and Share



Comments

Thank you for joining our conversations on NewsOK.com. We encourage your discussions but ask that you stay within the bounds of our terms and conditions. Please help us by reporting comments that violate these guidelines. To review our rules of engagement, go to Commenting and posting policy.

Editor's note: It is not our intent to offer comments on crime or fatality stories.

Leave a comment. Log in below or sign up (it's free).

   
You ask: "Who's to blame?"

How about Tery Don Phillips and Clemson for backing out of a contract earlier this year.
RAYMON, LAWTON - Aug 31, 2008 4:24 PM
Report as inappropriate
It was ever so fine a gesture for the OU fans to boo Chattanooga on to the field. :-0
Randall, Tulsa - Aug 31, 2008 4:03 PM
Report as inappropriate
Why is ou playing a high school team?
Bill, tulsa - Aug 30, 2008 7:43 PM
Report as inappropriate
Everyone's thinking OU is going to win big no matter who is in uniform. I smell a foul odor of over-confidence in the air from all my coworkers to the Sports Animal. Bold prediction...everyone's going to be disappointed because the margin of victory wasn't in the 70's and 80's. OU--35, Chattanooga--14.
Jeff, Norman - Aug 30, 2008 6:45 PM
Report as inappropriate
Clemson is rumored to have backed out.
Hiffdas, fdassfas - Aug 30, 2008 1:20 PM
Report as inappropriate
they left out that Ward Cleaver from the tv show leave it to beaver also played at mighty chattanooga....oh well, just saying.
barton, idabel - Aug 30, 2008 1:13 PM
Report as inappropriate
even if we needed a home opener, alot of people do not realize that the school gets to play a big time team and actually gets some quality experience by playing us and so i cannot blame them for playing us. i do miss north texas state playing us like they use to. so who cares how mediocre they are or never been heard of. they will come to play and get some good out of it and so will OU.
robert, cushing - Aug 30, 2008 11:34 AM
Report as inappropriate
Worse yet if a starter gets injured before Stoops pulls that starters out. It's no fun watching an under-skilled team get blown out. But then...but then...there IS that Appalachian State-Michigan incident last year...hmmmm
Richard, Tyler - Aug 30, 2008 10:15 AM
Report as inappropriate
quote from Berry: "Who's to blame for this historic mismatch? Start with us all." It took me while to get you, I do more and more each column. -well everyone's got to earn a living I guess. How right you are.

Travis, Lake Jackson - Aug 30, 2008 9:58 AM
Report as inappropriate