Share “Broken cookie outlet crumbles in Marietta”

Broken cookie outlet crumbles in Marietta

Bobby Ross Jr. Published: August 25, 2000

MARIETTA - The Keebler Elves have closed the lid on this southern Oklahoma community's biggest tourist attraction - its broken cookie store.

For 46 years, the "Cookie Shop" used highway signs to lure Interstate 35 travelers who had a sweet tooth, a couple of minutes to spare and 99 cents in their pockets.

"The Cookie Shop is really what's put Marietta on the map," said Bob Barr, program manager for the Marietta Business District Association.

But now it's gone - as quickly as one of those scrumptious cookie pieces with the lemon icing.

The Cookie Shop, which opened along U.S. 77 as the Little Brownie Bakers in 1954, is set to close at 5 p.m. today.

For good. Or bad, as many broken cookie lovers see it.

"I don't understand it," said Willis Choate, a civic leader and owner of the local newspaper, the Marietta Monitor.

Apparently, product liability concerns prompted Keebler to close the broken cookie outlet, city leaders said. The decision does not affect the 400-employee Murray Biscuit Co. cookie production plant, which Keebler owns.

It's just the broken cookies that have been crushed.

So, what about a cookie with a few chips off its block could possibly spark a consumer lawsuit?

The problem is that the ingredient labels on the mixed bags of broken cookies can't possibly list all the ingredients, Barr said.

"Therefore, if someone's allergic to peanuts, they might not know they're eating a cookie with peanuts in it," he said.

Continue reading this story on the... has disabled the comments for this article.