Share “Column: Ref! Ghost goals making football...”

Column: Ref! Ghost goals making football look dumb

Associated Press Published: October 8, 2012

Hey, referee! That was a goal! Or it was very, very close.

To be fair to Howard Webb and his team of touchline assistants, it wasn't humanly possible for them to judge whether it was or wasn't. It all happened in the blink of an eye.

The ball thudded off Manchester United's crossbar, down onto the turf and back up to head-height with Papiss Cisse. The Newcastle United striker from Senegal, not particularly tall but plenty quick, then head-butted it as hard as he possibly could at United's goal. Newcastle was 2-0 down at this point. A score from Cisse could have put his team back in the game.

But United's young Spanish 'keeper, David De Gea, got a gloved hand to it. Diving acrobatically to his left, he scooped the ball away — either as it was crossing, or after it had crossed, United's goal-line.

Which was it? We'll never know. Machines exist that could have told us. But they're still not being used in football— making the sport and people who run it look it silly.

Because this is silly. In years to come, we'll look back on this era when technology could have solved a glaring problem but wasn't quickly deployed and wonder how this was possible. How could administrators of the world's most popular game have been so boneheaded and sluggish?

Did-it-or-didn't-it-cross-the-line incidents are a serious but treatable disease for football. Medicines are there to vaccinate against it, in the shape of detection systems with cameras or sensors to tell referees when a goal is a goal. The medicine should have been administered long ago.

FIFA is getting there, slowly and proceeding with extreme caution and lashings of red tape. Like those who took so long to accept that the Earth revolves around the Sun, FIFA boss Sepp Blatter won't be remembered for his U-turn in 2010 when he finally recognized the need for goal-line technology but for the amount of time and evidence it took for him to reach that conclusion.

After rounds of testing over months and in different countries, proposed goal-line systems from eight companies have been whittled down to two: Hawk-Eye, using multiple cameras, and GoalRef, employing magnetic sensors. There'll be yet more testing, in competition this time, at FIFA's Club World Cup in Japan in December. That should clear the way for the use of these technologies at FIFA's Confederations Cup in Brazil next June and then for one or both to be used at Brazilian stadiums staging the World Cup in 2014.

Too late, in other words, to have helped Webb referee Newcastle against United on Sunday.

Even television replays and magnified freeze-frames couldn't provide a conclusive answer as to whether all of the ball crossed the line before de Gea slapped it away. In real time, at that speed, and without the benefit of replays, Webb's assistant can't be expected to have seen it, either.

United manager Alex Ferguson was honest enough to admit that it wouldn't have been an injustice if Webb had awarded a goal, "because I thought enough of the ball's over" the line.

Continue reading this story on the...