Share “Courts issue conflicting decisions on key...”

Courts issue conflicting decisions on key challenges to Obamacare

Issue over tax subsidies may ultimately be decided by U.S. Supreme Court. White House says there is no immediate impact on millions of Americans — including an estimated 55,000 Oklahomans — who will receive subsidies to purchase health insurance.
by Chris Casteel Published: July 22, 2014
Advertisement

photo - President Barack Obama speaks about the My Brother’s Keeper Initiative, at the Walker Jones Education Campus in Washington, Monday, July 21, 2014. President Obama announced that leaders of 60 of the largest school systems have pledged to expand minority boys' access to better preschools and advanced classes and to try to prevent grade retention, suspensions and expulsions. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)
President Barack Obama speaks about the My Brother’s Keeper Initiative, at the Walker Jones Education Campus in Washington, Monday, July 21, 2014. President Obama announced that leaders of 60 of the largest school systems have pledged to expand minority boys' access to better preschools and advanced classes and to try to prevent grade retention, suspensions and expulsions. (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite)

Two federal appeals courts issued conflicting decisions Tuesday on whether the Affordable Care Act allows Oklahomans and people in 35 other states to receive tax credits for health insurance purchased on federal exchanges.

The high-stakes dispute seems destined for the U.S. Supreme Court, which already has issued major rulings this year and in 2012 on the health care law. The tax subsidy issue threatens the economic framework of the law, which uses tax incentives and penalties to increase the number of insured Americans.

Libertarian and conservative opponents of the law discovered what they considered a fatal flaw in the wording regarding the tax subsidies and challenged it in three states and the District of Columbia.

One of the states is Oklahoma, where Attorney General Scott Pruitt has been fighting the Obama administration in federal court in Muskogee.

But the Oklahoma judge has been slow in comparison to ones in Washington, D.C., and in Virginia. Federal district judges in both jurisdictions ruled months ago that tax subsidies were available for policies bought on state exchanges or from the federal exchanges; those decisions were then immediately appealed.

On Tuesday, appeals courts here and in Richmond, Va., split on the matter. The D.C. circuit court ruled 2-1 that the tax subsidies are available only for insurance bought on exchanges established by states. The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 3-0 that the law allows subsidies for insurance purchased on state or federal exchanges.

White House spokesman Josh Earnest said Tuesday that “it’s important for people all across the country to understand that this (D.C. court) ruling does not have any practical impact on their ability to continue to receive tax credits right now.”

The U.S. Justice Department likely would ask the full D.C. circuit court to revisit the case, Earnest said, and the administration feels confident its argument — that Congress intended subsidies for both state and federal exchanges — ultimately would prevail.

“We feel strongly about the sound legal reasoning” of the administration’s case, Earnest said.

Pruitt statement

Pruitt said Tuesday that he expects a decision soon from a federal judge in Muskogee in the Oklahoma case.

He said the decision in the D.C. appeals court “is a victory for Oklahoma’s lawsuit and others challenging the law. Our lawsuit challenges the administration’s attempt to ‘fix’ the health care law through executive fiat.

Continue reading this story on the...

by Chris Casteel
Washington Bureau
Chris Casteel began working for The Oklahoman's Norman bureau in 1982 while a student at the University of Oklahoma. After covering the police beat, federal courts and the state Legislature in Oklahoma City, he moved to Washington in 1990, where...
+ show more


Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    ABC News Takes Over 'The View' As Ratings Dwindle (EXCLUSIVE)
  2. 2
    Dallas Nurse Nina Pham to Reunite With Dog Bentley
  3. 3
    KFOR: First grader comes home from school with bruises; mother infuriated
  4. 4
    KFOR: Mother struggles to survive after delivery
  5. 5
    Arizona Cardinals' Tony Jefferson dealing with concussion
+ show more