A state oversight agency has concluded the state Department of Human Services violated its own policies when it failed to close a Tulsa home day care months before a boy died after he was injured there.
The agency faulted DHS officials for not supporting a frustrated licensing worker who, a full year before the boy's death, sought to revoke the day care's license because of repeated problems there, including abuse.
The Oklahoma Commission on Children and Youth questioned DHS "philosophy, procedures and practices.”
Joshua Minton, 2, died May 17. The day care owner, Vicki Chiles, is charged with first-degree murder. Police say she admitted putting tape over Joshua's mouth and binding his hands because he was whining at nap time
DHS workers had found repeated problems at the Noah's Ark Child Care Home dating to 2003, such as children being left alone in a van, the oversight agency found.
Also, an assistant caretaker had admitted spanking a child and lying about it, records show.
The agency said Chiles also was refusing to take corrective steps, like going to behavior classes and cutting back on her hours of operation. She once said, "Licensing could not tell her when to be open,” records show.
But a regional manager refused in early 2006 to consider revoking the day care's license, writing, "Not enough at this time,” the agency found.
The Commission on Children and Youth also found DHS should have ordered the immediate closure of Chiles' home after she admitted to DHS workers on April 13 that she had struck an 8-year-old boy with a fly swatter.
DHS continuing coverage
Oversight agency's report and DHS response