Share “EEOC alleges employers disproportionately...”

EEOC alleges employers disproportionately used criminal checks against minorities

Paul Ross, a labor and employment attorney with McAfee & Taft, advises cautious use of criminal background checks.
by Paula Burkes Published: June 18, 2013

Q&A with Paul Ross

Attorney advises cautious use

of criminal background checks.

Q: The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission last week filed two lawsuits alleging employers engaged in race discrimination by conducting criminal background checks on its employees. Is it illegal for employers to perform these background checks?

A: No. Criminal background checks are legitimate tools employers can use. But if checks are used improperly, the process quickly can turn into an illegal one.

Q: Why would criminal background checks by employers be illegal?

A: The EEOC believes criminal background checks may have a disproportionate effect on minority individuals. A company may require all new hires to pass criminal background checks. But if the policy results in a higher number of minority individuals being screened out of employment opportunities, one might argue it has a disparate impact on that minority group. If that disparate impact is proven, the policy would be illegal under federal employment law.

Q: Was that the basis of the two suits filed earlier this week?

A: Yes. In both cases the EEOC appears to have argued the employers disproportionally screened out minority employees by using a criminal-background check process that appeared to apply to all groups equally. In one case, the EEOC alleged the employer rescinded 10 percent of the job offers it had made to black employees after conducting criminal background checks, while only 7 percent of job offers to nonblack candidates were rescinded for the same reason. According to the EEOC, this is a statistically significant disparity.

Continue reading this story on the...

by Paula Burkes
A 1981 journalism graduate of Oklahoma State University, Paula Burkes has more than 30 years experience writing and editing award-winning material for newspapers and healthcare, educational and telecommunications institutions in Tulsa, Oklahoma...
+ show more


  1. 1
    April Fools' Day 2015: The best and worst pranks
  2. 2
    8 Completely Useless Things Cluttering Up Your Home
  3. 3
    Germanwings crash: Reports of video from plane denied
  4. 4
    Inventor of Pet Rock dies at 78
  5. 5
    EEOC worker pilfered $60k in taxpayer funds for Louis Vitton, Disneyland
+ show more