Fact-checking pastors' claims about “The Most Fabulous Story Ever Told”

by William Crum Modified: December 2, 2013 at 12:00 pm •  Published: December 2, 2013

Dozens of pastors have signed a letter to elected officials objecting to “The Most Fabulous Story Ever Told.” Oklahoma City Theatre Company is producing Paul Rudnick's play at Civic Center Music Hall. The play has homosexual characters, satirizes biblical stories and includes scenes of simulated gay sex. The pastors' letter states that the play “is obscene and is an affront to Oklahoma City community standards.” Here's a look at three points made by the pastors to support their argument.

Pastors: “It is quite possible that this production meets the definition of obscenity and might be in violation of federal and state obscenity laws.”

To be found obscene, depictions of sexual conduct must be “patently offensive as found by the average person applying contemporary community standards” and be found — when taken as a whole — to appeal to “prurient interest in sex,” again by the average person applying community standards. Additionally, it must be shown that a “reasonable person” would find a performance, taken as a whole, lacks serious literary value.

“I didn't see enough data in the ministers' letter to conclude that an obscenity prosecution was possible or plausible,” said Rick Tepker, who teaches First Amendment law at the University of Oklahoma College of Law. “They have to pass all three tests, and I think they flunk two.”

Pastors: “Why is the state of Oklahoma funding the Arts Council with tax dollars if they use the money to promote pornography?”

| |

by William Crum
OU and Norman High School graduate, formerly worked as a reporter and editor for the Associated Press, the Star Tribune in Minneapolis, and the Norman Transcript. Married, two children, lives in Norman.
+ show more


Trending Now


  1. 1
    Man who plunged from Denver balcony ate 6 times recommended amount of pot cookie
  2. 2
    Chelsea Manning named Honorary Marshal in San Francisco's Gay Pride Parade
  3. 3
    'Scandal' serves up explosive season finale!
  4. 4
    South Korea ferry disaster: Rescued vice-principal found hanging from tree
  5. 5
    Former OU coach Sunny Golloway goes off at Auburn
+ show more