David Earls returns to McAlester courthouse - Article Photos 1/1

This April 5, 2003 photo obtained from the Oklahoma Department of Corrections shows David Harold Earls. Two state lawmakers are questioning a plea agreement that will allow Earls to serve only one year in jail on a conviction for raping a 4-year-old girl. Nineteen of the 20 years of a sentence against 64-year-old Earls were suspended as part of a plea agreement reached May 13, 2009 with Pittsburg County prosecutors. (AP Photo/Oklahoma Department of Corrections)