Article Photos: A crack in legal unanimity for gay marriage 2/2

File-This photo taken July 16, 2008 shows Federal Appellate Court Judge Paul  J. Kelly.  Kelly, was in the minority in his opinion as the two other judges on the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals panel found the U.S. Constitution protects the rights of gay couples to marry. Kelly has broken the string of 16 state and federal judges who sided with gay marriage advocates in cases across the country over the past year. (AP Photo/The Santa Fe New Mexican, Natalie Guillen)