Share “George F. Will: A case for targeted killings”

George F. Will: A case for targeted killings

Published: December 9, 2012
Advertisement

Today's war is additionally complicated by the fact that, as Yoo says, America's enemy “resembles a network, not a nation.” Its commanders and fighters do not wear uniforms; they hide among civilian populations and are not parts of a transparent command and control apparatus. Drones enable the U.S. military — which, regarding drones, includes the CIA; an important distinction has been blurred — to wield a technology especially potent against al-Qaida's organization and tactics. All its leaders are, effectively, military, not civilian. Killing them serves the military purposes of demoralizing the enemy, preventing planning, sowing confusion and draining the reservoir of experience.

Most U.S. wars have been fought with military mass sustained by economic might. But as Yoo says, today's war is against a diffuse enemy that has no territory to invade and no massed forces to crush. So the war cannot be won by producing more tanks, army divisions or naval forces. The United States can win only by destroying al-Qaida's “ability to function — by selectively killing or capturing its key members.”

After the terrorist bombings of two U.S. embassies in East Africa in 1998, the Bill Clinton administration launched cruise missiles against suspected terrorist camps in Afghanistan, hoping bin Laden was there. If the missiles had killed him, would this have been improper? In March 2003, in the hours before the invasion of Iraq, the George W. Bush administration, thinking it knew where Saddam Hussein was, launched a cruise missile strike against one of his compounds. Was it wrong to try to economize violence by decapitating his regime? Would it have been morally preferable to attempt this by targeting, with heavy bombing, not a person but his neighborhood? Surely not.

George Will's email address is georgewill@washpost.com.

WASHINGTON POST WRITERS GROUP


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    Judge declines divorce case, citing gay marriage ruling
  2. 2
    Crowdfunding For Real Estate: Buyer Beware
  3. 3
    10 affordable countries that budget travelers can't miss
  4. 4
    These wearables double as travel gadgets
  5. 5
    Police return woman’s stolen car — with drugs, weapons added
+ show more

FEATURED JOBS



× Trending opinion Article