Health care ruling: Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin says state needs to study implications of the high court decision

Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin and GOP legislative leaders say they're hoping the federal health care law will be tossed out if a new president and enough Republicans are elected to the Senate in November.
BY MICHAEL MCNUTT mmcnutt@opubco.com Published: June 29, 2012

Oklahoma's Republican leaders who delayed implementing provisions of the federal health care law in hopes it would be thrown out by the U.S. Supreme Court reacted Thursday with a lack of urgency after the high court upheld most of the legislation backed by President Barack Obama.

Now they are hoping the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act will be thrown out by means of a Republican presidential victory in the Nov. 6 general election.

“This November we have an election coming up not only for the president of the United States but for Congress,” Gov. Mary Fallin said. “This summer and this fall the people of Oklahoma, the people of our nation will have the chance to voice their opinion about how they feel about the federal health care law once again when they go to the polls and vote. Certainly I am hoping that we'll elect a new president and we'll be able to change faces ... in the (Democratic-controlled) U.S. Senate that we can once and for all overturn the federal health care bill.”

GOP legislative leaders had the same attitude.

“Our best hope now is to elect those willing to repeal this law and work together to find better solutions to the significant health care challenges faced by our state and nation,” said House Speaker Kris Steele, R-Shawnee.

“We must turn our focus toward November and elect leaders who will repeal and replace Obamacare,” said Senate President Pro Tem Brian Bingman, R-Sapulpa.

Oklahoma's law

Fallin and GOP legislative leaders last year turned down a $54.6 million grant to develop a health care exchange, or state-based marketplace, where residents would shop for private health insurance products. The exchange is a component of the federal health care law.

Fallin, Steele and Bingman at first accepted the money, but changed positions after hearing complaints from Republicans and conservatives. Voters in November 2010 approved a state question that prevents Oklahomans from being forced to buy health insurance, which is another part of the federal health care law.

“The people of Oklahoma spoke very clearly last November when they said that they didn't believe the federal health care bill was the right solution for the state of Oklahoma, so we listened to the people,” Fallin said Thursday.

It's uncertain what effect the ruling will have on the state constitutional change. Usually the supremacy clause in the U.S. Constitution states that federal law supersedes state law.

Fallin said she was extremely disappointed and frustrated with the Supreme Court's ruling and that she still considered the measure unconstitutional. She said she will be working with her legal staff and state agencies to determine what the implications are for Oklahoma.

“At this point in time, we really don't know what this means to the state of Oklahoma,” she said.

Delayed action

A legislative joint committee in February recommended lawmakers take steps to establish an exchange similar to the one in Utah, which was established before the national health care law was written. Legislative leaders a month later decided to take no action on the legislation until after the Supreme Court ruled on the constitutionality of the national health care law.

The federal health care law requires states to submit plans for health insurance exchanges if states don't want to use a federal system. The federal government will impose its version of an insurance exchange on states that don't set up their own.

The deadline to have a plan submitted to the federal government is Jan. 1. The system should be operational a year later.

Fallin said she didn't know if the state could have a plan by the Jan. 1 deadline.

The legislative committee recommended that the Oklahoma exchange be housed in the Insure Oklahoma program, which would be spun off from the Oklahoma Health Care Authority and turned into a public trust. Insure Oklahoma allows people whose employer does not offer health insurance to get coverage and pay premiums.

Continue reading this story on the...