Illegal Park Service projects damage sacred site

Published on NewsOK Modified: May 10, 2014 at 9:40 am •  Published: May 10, 2014
Advertisement
;

IOWA CITY, Iowa (AP) — National Park Service officials approved $3 million in illegal construction projects over a decade that damaged one of the nation's most sacred American Indian burial sites, but few have been punished for the bureaucratic failure, records show.

Phyllis Ewing, the former superintendent of Effigy Mounds National Monument, and subordinate Tom Sinclair repeatedly ignored laws that required archaeological studies and input from tribes before building boardwalks, trails and a maintenance shed at the federally protected site in northeast Iowa, according to investigation documents posted this week on the park service's website.

Regional officials in Omaha, Nebraska, uncovered the violations in 2009 but waited years to take disciplinary action against Ewing, whose attorney told The Associated Press she was fired Feb. 28 and is contesting the decision.

While no human remains were affected, one tribal leader complained that officials treated his ancestors' cemeteries "as places to walk your dog," records show. Another said the projects were "monuments to government stupidity."

The Mississippi River Valley site was created by President Harry Truman in 1949 to preserve "a significant phase of mound building culture of prehistoric American Indians." It contains 200 mounds — some shaped like bears and birds — affiliated with 12 tribes.

National Park Service employees blamed Ewing and Sinclair for pursuing the illegal developments in a misguided effort to make the site more accessible to those with disabilities. Some also blamed a lack of oversight for allowing construction that removed stone artifacts and impacted scenic views.

"We've tried to understand how a park can behave so badly. Wherever they had a chance to screw up, they did," one regional official said in a 2011 investigative interview, adding the actions "destroyed the park and it will take decades of hard work" to repair the damage.

The agency hasn't removed two of three boardwalks, years after acknowledging they wouldn't have been built had employees followed the National Historic Preservation Act and other laws.

Jeff Ruch, executive director of Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, said Ewing oversaw "a stunning pattern of cultural resource desecration."

"The park service may have set a new record in dithering by waiting five years to take any kind of formal action in a case that's this outrageous," said Ruch, who uncovered the records through the Freedom of Information Act.

Continue reading this story on the...