Share “Lawsuit alleges income tax reduction...”

Lawsuit alleges income tax reduction measures violates state Constitution

Lawsuit by Jerry Fent alleges income tax reduction measure is unconstitutional on procedural grounds
by Rick Green Modified: May 22, 2014 at 4:37 pm •  Published: May 22, 2014

An Oklahoma City attorney who has successfully sued the state before is asking the state Supreme Court to throw out an income tax reduction law on the basis that it violates the state Constitution.

Jerry Fent says in the lawsuit filed Thursday that bills affecting state revenue need to originate in the House, and this bill started in the Senate. He also says such bills require a three-fourths vote in the Oklahoma House and Senate, and the approval of this bill did not reach that threshold.

Gov. Mary Fallin, who is named as defendant in the lawsuit, had no comment. A hearing is scheduled for June 24 before a referee who will recommend whether the state’s highest court should take up the case.

On April 28, Fallin signed into law Senate Bill 1246, calling for a gradual reduction in the state’s top personal income tax rate from 5.25 to 4.85 percent. The cut is to begin to take effect for the 2016 tax year if general revenue meets benchmarks set forth in the legislation.

The bill passed the Senate, 32-10, and the House, 54-40.

Senate President Pro Tem Brian Bingman, R-Sapulpa, expressed confidence the court would uphold the law.

“We disagree with Mr. Fent’s assessment and are hopeful the courts will as well,” Bingman said. “When the people of Oklahoma added this provision to our state’s constitution in 1992, it was clear that it was meant to protect Oklahomans from tax hikes, not tax cuts. We believe the courts will agree that this lawsuit represents a manipulation of the intent of this constitutional provision and will be thrown out, allowing Oklahomans to see a reduction in their taxes as promised.”

Continue reading this story on the...

by Rick Green
Capitol Bureau Chief
Rick Green is the Capitol Bureau Chief of The Oklahoman. A graduate of Humboldt State University in Arcata, Calif., he worked as news editor for The Associated Press in Oklahoma City before joining The Oklahoman.
+ show more

Trending Now


  1. 1
    Commission hears report critical of Oklahoma's handling of new teacher evaluations
  2. 2
    State Rep. Sally Kern withdraws bill that would have allowed businesses to discrimnate against gays
  3. 3
    Police union spokesman pushes young black woman at public hearing on civilian review
  4. 4
    Helmerich & Payne to lay off 2,000 employees despite $203 million profit
  5. 5
    Police investigating officer-involved shooting in Stillwater
+ show more