Share “Let citizens decide if lottery payout plan...”

Let citizens decide if lottery payout plan should change

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board Published: December 10, 2012
Advertisement

REDUCE the payout rate, increase the sales. Increase the sales, increase the payout.

Reduce tax rates and tax revenues, increase economic growth. Increase economic growth, increase tax revenues.

These two formulas follow a nearly identical line of thinking, but those who support one tend to oppose the other.

The first involves the state lottery and the requirement that education get an automatic 35 percent payout of lottery profits. The second involves state personal income taxes. Conservative Republicans tend to oppose lowering the lottery payout rate but support lowering the top income tax rate.

The Oklahoma Lottery Commission has tried for years to reduce the education payout, claiming that it results in lower prizes and that lower prizes result in lower sales of lottery tickets. The argument is that by reducing the education payout rate, prizes will rise, ticket sales will rise, profits will rise and education will get more money from, say, a 30 percent payout than it's getting from 35 percent.

In the tax arena, the argument is that a lower income tax rate will stimulate economic growth, incomes will rise, tax revenue will rise and the state will get more money from, say, a 4.75 percent maximum tax rate than it's getting from the current 5.25 percent.

Both propositions are based on assumptions that may or may not prove true. That alone is no reason to oppose them. However, a reduction in the lottery's education payout rate is problematic. The people approved the lottery and the payout formula. Changing the formula is best done by the people, not by legislative fiat.

So far the Legislature has been cool to the idea of a payout change. Conservative Republicans opposed the very concept of a state lottery when it came before voters in 2004. Nevertheless, the proposition passed with about 65 percent of the vote. Opposing a formula change now may be related to opposition to the lottery in general more than it is to the payout change in particular.

Continue reading this story on the...

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board
The Oklahoman Editorial Board consists of Gary Pierson, President and CEO of The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Christopher P. Reen, president and publisher of The Oklahoman; Kelly Dyer Fry, editor and vice president of news; Christy Gaylord...
+ show more


Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    Tulsa secret Santa pays off Wal-Mart layaways, hands out gift cards
  2. 2
    Cuban-born Tulsans have different perspectives on policy shift
  3. 3
    Bo Pelini rips Nebraska A.D. Shawn Eichorst in expletive-filled talk during final meeting with...
  4. 4
    More theaters bail on 'The Interview' in wake of hackers' threat
  5. 5
    Tulsa Washington alum Tyler Lockett on AFCA Coaches' All-American Team
+ show more