Minn. nurse staffing debate exposes partisan rift

Published on NewsOK Modified: February 21, 2013 at 11:25 am •  Published: February 21, 2013
Advertisement
;

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — Minnesota lawmakers fell into partisan camps Thursday as a House panel advanced a bill seeking state regulations on the number of nurses working shifts in hospitals.

The Democratic-led House Labor, Workplace, and Regulated Industries Committee endorsed the nurse staffing bill on a 9-6 party-line vote after hearing charged testimony from both sides in a long-simmering dispute. Unionized nurses argued the standards are needed to ensure patient safety, and hospital industry professionals cast it as government intrusion in medical decision-making.

The concept of staffing ratios has been a hot topic for years at the bargaining table, but the Minnesota Nurses Association sees opportunity with a Democratic-dominated state government to gain advantage in law. A bill the union is promoting doesn't include explicit quotas but it would demand hospital-by-hospital staffing requirements that would be developed over the next year. The standards would differ by unit and by the severity of patient health woes.

"If hospitals won't listen to nurses that we're stretched too thin to properly change dressings, then perhaps they'll listen to you," said Joe Howard, a registered nurse in an intensive care burn unit at a Duluth hospital.

Lawrence Massa, president of the Minnesota Hospital Association, accused the nurses union of working to "undermine the collective bargaining process" by getting lawmakers to intervene on their behalf. He noted that the standards would apply to all hospitals even though a majority of the facilities in the state aren't unionized and most get high marks for quality care.