Share “More creative thinking about Oklahoma's...”

More creative thinking about Oklahoma's A-F grading system for schools

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board Published: December 31, 2012

RELEASE of A through F grades for state schools has led to some creative thinking. Sadly, much of that creativity has been expended explaining away bad grades rather than improving school performance.

The latest example comes from an Oklahoma Policy Institute guest blog authored by Jonathan Willner, an economics professor at Oklahoma City University. Willner says “multivariate regression” analysis reveals “that a good part of what is being graded is the parents” and that it's merely “convenient to blame the schools.”

Well, yes, it is convenient to blame schools for the educational product they produce — sort of like it's convenient to blame Ford when its Pinto model explodes on impact. And convenient to blame the restaurant if a meal gives you food poisoning. In fact, it's convenient and correct to assign blame for product or service failure on those in charge of providing them.

If public schools don't exist to educate children, regardless of family background, then many citizens may wonder why we're pouring billions of taxpayer dollars into the public school system. We know your students are doomed to fail, but here's a few million anyway, just for kicks?

The state report cards for schools focus on student achievement, overall student growth, improvement of lowest-quartile students and whole school performance, which includes factors such as student attendance, graduation rates, advanced coursework, school climate surveys, and parent and community engagement.

Willner claims “a significant part” of the grade developed using those factors “is driven by the socio-economic condition of the parents of the children in the school.” He says his analysis was able to accurately predict 57 percent of school grades based on socio-economic factors.

That may sound compelling at first glance, but it means Willner failed to predict 43 percent of school grades. He admits missing the mark for more than 700 schools. That's pretty telling and indicates some schools are doing well in spite of poor student demographics while other middle-class schools are underperforming.

Continue reading this story on the...

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board
The Oklahoman Editorial Board consists of Gary Pierson, President and CEO of The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Christopher P. Reen, president and publisher of The Oklahoman; Kelly Dyer Fry, editor and vice president of news; Christy Gaylord...
+ show more


  1. 1
    Amazon Is Developing a Galaxy Quest TV Show
  2. 2
    'Les Miserables' actor Kyle Jean-Baptiste dies after fall -
  3. 3
    VICE: It's Time to Accept Video Games As Art
  4. 4
    What if your boss paid you to have life experiences for 3 months?
  5. 5
    Study: Sometimes the 'irrational' choice is the best one
+ show more


× Trending opinion Article