Share “Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt...”

Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt explains health care lawsuit on Capitol Hill

Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt says he sued United States because the IRS ignored the health care mandate's key provisions.
by Chris Casteel Published: July 31, 2013

“That was their option within the law, but now the IRS and Treasury's rule has invalidated my state's decision, harmed many employers and workers in my state and added to the federal deficit.”

Emily S. McMahon, a Treasury Department official who was involved in the IRS rule-making, said repeatedly on Wednesday that the department's interpretation essentially equating federal exchanges with state exchanges was “consistent with the statute as a whole.”

Lankford said there was no evidence the department carefully considered the question.

Simon Lazarus, a constitutional attorney, testified that the law's purpose was to provide nearly universal health care coverage. In context of the law and its goal, he said, the interpretation by Pruitt and others in regard to the exchanges was “highly implausible.”

Objection to hearing

Democrats on the subcommittee blasted the hearing as improper, considering Pruitt's ongoing case.

Rep. Jackie Speier, of California, the top Democrat on the subcommittee, told Lankford that he should steer the panel away from asking questions that could jeopardize a fair trial.

“Otherwise, I believe you may, intentionally or not, permit the legal process to be tainted by political interference,” Speier said.

Moreover, she said, “If Mr. Pruitt's lawsuit were to prevail, all he would achieve is making health care unaffordable to over 300,000 Oklahomans who would no longer be able to receive premium tax credits to help them buy health insurance in Oklahoma.”

A legal victory for Pruitt, she said, would be “a terrible loss for the lower-income people of Oklahoma who pay the attorney general's salary and whose taxes are even underwriting the very lawsuit that would deny them benefits.”

by Chris Casteel
Washington Bureau
Chris Casteel began working for The Oklahoman's Norman bureau in 1982 while a student at the University of Oklahoma. After covering the police beat, federal courts and the state Legislature in Oklahoma City, he moved to Washington in 1990, where...
+ show more


  1. 1
    American dentist said to have paid $55K to kill beloved lion in Africa
  2. 2
    KFOR: Oklahoma City attorney charged with federal sex crimes wants children allowed in his home
  3. 3
    CEO shares $27 million with staff after selling his firm
  4. 4
    Being topless in public is legal, woman reminds others after police encounter
  5. 5
    Naked, knife-wielding suspect serenades police with banjo
+ show more