That certainly happened with Gilbert, when he tallied two interceptions against the Longhorns, including one returned 43 yards for a score.
Still, Gilbert was surprised when cornerbacks coach Van Malone broke the news that he was heading to Orlando.
“It was totally unexpected,” Gilbert said. “From not being on the top 15, the semifinal list. Just to make that jump, for me, was an impressive jump.
“I think it really came down to me making plays, and those guys up front allowing me to make those plays. The defensive line getting tremendous pass rush on the quarterback and just me making breaks on the ball. Everybody's doing their job.”
Gilbert has stiff competition for the award in Florida State's Lamarcus Joyner and Michigan State's Darqueze Dennard. Both lead squads that are conference champions and rank in the top 6 in the nation in scoring defense, total defense and passing defense.
And Gilbert's final two games — where he was slowed by that shoulder injury and could not corral a near-interception that would have clinched a Cowboy win in Bedlam — may impact his chances of winning.
Regardless, though, Gilbert called his subpar 2012 season a “minor setback for a major comeback.” Sitting amongst college football's best players, as a contender for the Thorpe Award, proves he's accomplished that goal.
“There's a lot of good (defensive backs) out there,” Griffin said. “Being from Oklahoma, we're glad that Justin Gilbert made the finalist list.”
THORPE AWARD FINALISTS
Oklahoma State cornerback Justin Gilbert is a finalist for the Jim Thorpe Award given annually to the nation's best defensive back.
Here's a look at the other two finalists
Lamarcus Joyner, safety, Florida State
Led the Seminoles with five sacks and finished second on the team with 64 tackles, including 6.5 for loss. Also added two interceptions, four pass breakups, three quarterback hurries and three forced fumbles to anchor a team that led the nation in scoring defense (10.7 points per game) and passing defense (152 yards per game).
Darqueze Dennard, cornerback, Michigan State
Finished with four interceptions and 10 pass breakups for the nation's leader in total defense (248.2 yards per game). Also added 59 tackles (2.5 for loss), five quarterback hurries and two forced fumbles.