Share “OU athletic director Joe Castiglione talks...”

OU athletic director Joe Castiglione talks college football playoff, says regular season must be protected

A college football playoff is coming to a season near you, provided the sport's power-brokers do something they haven't always done. Compromise. So says OU athletic director Joe Castiglione, one of those decision-makers.
by Berry Tramel Published: May 16, 2012
Advertisement

A college football playoff is coming to a season near you, provided the sport's power-brokers do something they haven't always done.

Compromise.

So says OU athletic director Joe Castiglione, one of those decision-makers.

An expansion of the current two-team playoff to a four-team format is in the works and could be decided this summer. But the proposed models are many, and the agendas are many for the various conferences and schools.

“I do think people are genuine and sincere in trying to move change forward,” Castiglione said. “People are willing to accept change, but how much change are they willing to accept?

“May not lead to a perfect solution. Perhaps a perfect solution is unattainable. We, all of us, the public, may just have to be OK with that for now, because it is a step in the right direction.”

Castiglione said the Sooner priority is clear: protection of the regular season. He said President David Boren, and the Big 12 as a whole, agrees.

Preservation and enhancement of the regular season is vital to Castiglione.

“If our regular season is strong, our postseason will be strong, too,” Joe C. said. “If we make this all about the postseason, we will have made one of the colossal errors in college football.”

What does preservation or enhancement of the regular season mean? Castiglione admitted the answer is abstract. But he tried to explain.

“Every Saturday matters,” Castiglione said. “The idea that when we host football games on our campuses, it's important. We don't have that in college basketball right now. Whether that is a fair or an unfair comparison …

“The games need to matter in the minds of the stakeholders in college football. That's what draws television ratings and ticket-holders. That's what draws attention to the sport in general.”

Some of the proposed models include limiting the four participants to conference champions. Which would certainly promote the regular season. However, that comes with ramifications.

What about Notre Dame? What about an elite runner-up, like Alabama in 2011 or Texas in 2008? What if the Big 12, with no championship game, has a tie for the title?

“One thing has to be understood,” Castiglione said. “Each model creates a set of consequences. The group has to be willing to accept those consequences. That is where it gets difficult.

“Some people want certain things protected. My cautionary statement is we must continue to discuss and think it through and allow the process to take place before you put a stake in the ground that can't be moved.

“It will be most difficult getting enough votes to support a single model.”

But Joe C. did admit that the discussions have gone too far, the public appetite for a four-team tournament has grown too anticipated, for college football to not do something.

And once the format is adopted, the debate starts all over again with the decision on a selection process. Thankfully, Castiglione said, that's the chicken-egg order. Most decision-makers agree that the model needs to be established before the selection process, be it the old BCS rankings, a revamped BCS formula or even some kind of selection committee.

Continue reading this story on the...

by Berry Tramel
Columnist
Berry Tramel, a lifelong Oklahoman, sports fan and newspaper reader, joined The Oklahoman in 1991 and has served as beat writer, assistant sports editor, sports editor and columnist. Tramel grew up reading four daily newspapers — The Oklahoman,...
+ show more


Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    OU football: Golden Hat No. 1 in college football rivalry trophy rankings
  2. 2
    Johnny Manziel: Intoxicated fan had toyed with him
  3. 3
    Science Says Dogs Really Do Understand What People Say To Them
  4. 4
    'Shut It Down': Dozens Of Ferguson Protesters Interrupt Black Friday Shopping At Wal-Mart, Target
  5. 5
    Netflix CEO: Broadcast TV Will Be Dead By 2030
+ show more