OU football fans are too quick to judge Tim Kish, incoming class of recruits

Two things, in particular, seem to be bugging the Sooners supporters: First, the name Tim Kish did not wow enough as a hire for the linebackers opening. Secondly, in the recruiting class that will officially sign Wednesday is not up to the lofty standard.
BY TRAVIS HANEY Modified: January 29, 2012 at 7:04 pm •  Published: January 29, 2012

NORMAN — Certainly not all, or even most, but a faction of Oklahoma fans has been crabby with me in recent weeks in communication via email and Twitter.

Two things, in particular, seem to be bugging the Sooners supporters: First, the name Tim Kish did not wow enough as a hire for the linebackers opening. Secondly, the recruiting class that will officially sign Wednesday is not up to the lofty standard.

To each concern, I say this: Give them a chance.

Some of you are and will, I realize, but perhaps not enough of OU fans are withholding knee-jerk judgment. I'm a firm believer that, for a variety of reasons, past results don't always necessarily dictate those in the future.

That thought extends especially to the recruits. They're not even on campus yet, and this class has already been labeled as substandard? Just because of a dot or star or grade, or whatever system establishes worth to those who play high school football?

Maybe this class is sorry. I don't know. I'm just inclined to believe that's something to be evaluated in two or three years. As an example, remember that Frank Alexander was something of an underachiever until his senior season – when he took it upon himself to become the Big 12's best defensive player.

I was watching “Miracle” this weekend while running at the gym. It's a fantastic movie, one I hadn't seen in a while. There's a scene early in the film I had forgotten about, in which legendary – and late – coach Herb Brooks tells the U.S. hockey association types that he knows who he wants on his team after only one day of tryouts.

They guffaw. Even the loyal assistant coach, Craig Patrick, does not understand.

“But some of the best players aren't on the roster,” Patrick pleads.

Brooks laughs at him, says he isn't interested in the best players; he wants the right players.

That's how you've got to assemble a football team, correct? My friend Bruce Feldman noted Saturday that four of USC's five “5-star” guys from two years ago had already left the program, though the remaining one, receiver Robert Woods, is excellent.

Too many 5-stars, too many divas? Conceivably. Give me the 3-star who loves OU, doesn't mind working his tail off and is addicted to winning.

A guy like David Smith sort of strikes me that way. The Sooners found him way late, after the run of running back transfers. Maybe he winds up being one of those guys, maybe he doesn't. But don't you love those stories of undervalued players – those first-blush judged – who wind up being cornerstones?



Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    Baylor's Shawn Oakman not impressed by OU's win over Alabama in Sugar Bowl
  2. 2
    Dez Bryant, three Sooners in NFL trade value top 50 (so far)
  3. 3
    Johnny Manziel's No. 2 leads NFL in jersey sales
  4. 4
    You're more likely to get a raise now
  5. 5
    Google has a plan to speed up the Web
+ show more