Prior complaints
Report details DHS visits to where child died

 
By Randy Ellis | Modified: May 24, 2007 at 3:57 pm | Published: May 1, 2007   

The Oklahoma Department of Human Services received four complaints about William Barnard or his siblings living in dirty or unsafe conditions in the 16 months before Barnard's March 21 drowning death, according to a DHS report released Monday.

More Info

Report on DHS visits


William Barnard
Incidents documented before March '07
November 2005
The 2005 complaint concerned an allegation that William's older sister often was sent to pre-kindergarten "dirty and unkempt in general appearance.” The girl reportedly had not returned to school after being sent home with head lice.

DHS said that complaint "did not fall within the scope of neglect, as there is no mandatory statutory requirement that a child must attend pre-kindergarten.”

March 2006
DHS said it received a complaint stating on Feb. 1, 2006, William's then 4-year-old sister "was observed to be dirty and that her mother, Alzaina Marie Barnard, had written ‘I'm a looser' (sic) on one arm and ‘I like boys' on the other arm of the child.”

DHS said a child welfare worker went to the home and confirmed that the girl and her brother were dirty, but saw no injuries. The child welfare worker said the girl was developmentally delayed and couldn't have written the words on her own arms, but the adults in the home denied any knowledge of the writing.

"The explanation given was that perhaps some other children on the school bus could have written on the child's arm,” the DHS report said.

The family was referred to the department's Family Support Division.

August 2006
This time, the complaint alleged William and his sister were living in "an extremely filthy home infested with roaches as well as having boards on the front porch with large rusty nails sticking up.

"William was reported to be filthy and had a red and swollen unclean wound from where his gastric feeding tube had been removed the previous week. The five-year-old sibling was reported to have two large bruises.”

A child welfare worker again visited the home and confirmed the children were dirty. The worker said the mother said the bruises on her daughter were caused by the girl falling after crawling on a kitchen counter top to reach a cabinet. The worker asked that William be seen by a medical professional, which was done, the report said, adding that no infection was found.

The report said the DHS worker revisited the home Sept. 15 and found conditions had improved, adding that the investigation was closed with a recommendation that the family continue receiving services.

Where the case stands now

On Monday, William's sister and a younger brother were in state custody, DHS officials said.

Related content

NewsOK Related Articles

William's mother, Alzaina Marie Barnard, 25, was charged with child neglect April 13 after an investigator looking into the drowning said she admitted leaving the 3-year-old boy with Down syndrome and his 5-year-old sister in a bathtub for at least 2 hours while she played "Spades” on the Internet.

DHS has come under criticism because the Barnard children were returned to their home upon the recommendation of a child welfare worker just three days after Oklahoma City police had removed them, citing squalid living conditions.

Officers reported the home was filled with an overwhelming stench, trash, loose electrical wires, moldy pizza, roach bodies, mice droppings and handprints of children on a bathroom wall that appeared to have been made with human feces.

Page 1 of 2



Related Topics: Crime, Child Abuse, Crime and Law

NewsOK has disabled the comments for this article.
See our commenting and posting policy.


53yr Old Woman, Looks 25
53yr Old Mom publishes 1 simple wrinkle trick that has angered doctors.
www.ConsumerLifestyleMag.com
Woman is 51 But Looks 25
Mom reveals simple wrinkle secret that has angered doctors...
ConsumerLifestyles.org

News Photo Galleriesview all