PRETORIA, South Africa (AP) — In closing arguments in a murder trial that has riveted South Africa and many around the world, the chief prosecutor said Thursday that Olympian Oscar Pistorius dropped "the baton of truth" and produced a succession of lies to save himself from a conviction for shooting to death his girlfriend.
Likening the sensational trial to the sport that made the double-amputee runner world-famous, Gerrie Nel said Pistorius had lost this race and urged the judge to convict him of premeditated murder for killing Reeva Steenkamp. The charge carries a sentence of at least 25 years and up to life in prison.
Nel said Pistorius' explanation that he acted out of fear there was a dangerous intruder hiding in a toilet cubicle in his bathroom was "absolutely devoid of any truth." Nel criticized Pistorius in the Pretoria courtroom, saying he was an "appalling witness" ready to lie at every chance to cover up a murder. The chief prosecutor spoke for nearly five hours, using the 109-page written argument the prosecution submitted to the court last week.
Chief defense lawyer Barry Roux listened and checked files as Nel spoke. Judge Thokozile Masipa occasionally questioned Nel, and urged him at one point to speed up. At the start of closing arguments, she had warned the lawyers they had only until the end of Friday to complete them in court.
"Unless, of course, you want to work on a Saturday and perhaps Sunday, after church," she said, smiling.
The defense repeated its claim that police had tampered with crucial evidence at the scene, but Roux had only started his final arguments when Judge Masipa postponed proceedings until Friday for the defense to finish.
That day is scheduled to be the 41st and final day of proceedings before Masipa adjourns to consider a verdict with her two legal assessors, five months after the trial opened. South Africa has no trial by jury and there are no limits on how long Masipa may take to reach her judgment.
Pistorius could also be convicted of a lesser murder charge or negligent killing, both of which call for years in jail. The judge could acquit him if she believes he only made a tragic error.
Nel argued that Masipa should still convict Pistorius of murder, even if she accepts his story that he didn't know it was Steenkamp behind the door. Either way, Pistorius armed himself with his 9 mm pistol on Feb. 14, 2013 and shot four times with the intention to kill someone and with no reason to believe his life was in danger, Nel said.
Continue reading this story on the...