Share “Reeling in decision-makers would loosen...”

Reeling in decision-makers would loosen the noose on college athletes

Coaches and administrators have not protected the athletes in their charge. Coaches and administrators talk about the high ideals on which college athletics is based. They do not practice them.
by Berry Tramel Published: March 27, 2014
Advertisement

photo - FILE - In this Sept. 21, 2013 file photo, Northwestern quarterback Kain Colter (2), wears APU for
FILE - In this Sept. 21, 2013 file photo, Northwestern quarterback Kain Colter (2), wears APU for "All Players United" on wrist tape as he scores a touchdown during an NCAA college football game against Maine in Evanston, Ill. The decision to allow Northwestern football players to unionize raises an array of questions for college sports. Among them, state schools vs. public schools, powerhouse programs vs. smaller colleges. (AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh, File)

An $18,000 bonus kicked in Saturday for Ohio State athletic director Gene Smith. Courtesy of wrestler Logan Stieber, who won the 133-pound NCAA championship at Chesapeake Arena.

All of a sudden, that Northwestern University football union doesn’t seem like such a bad idea.

A National Labor Relations Board official this week ruled that Northwestern football players can unionize and collectively bargain with the Big Ten school.

A college football union. Sounds like a terrible idea on the surface – a goofy mix of union organizers with coddled athletes who already have it cushy.

Until you remember who’s on the other side of the potential bargaining table. Coaches and administrators who have not protected the athletes in their charge. Coaches and administrators talk about the high ideals on which college athletics is based. They do not practice them.

If they did, the Northwestern union would be unnecessary or would have different stated goals.

The front man for the union, former Northwestern quarterback Kain Colter, says a potential union would not push to pay athletes. Rather, the union wants to protect athletes and free them from unfair constraints. Of which there are many.

Don’t misunderstand. Collegiate athletes aren’t mistreated. Many are given a wonderful opportunity; play the sport they love, in exchange for a free education, great contacts for their post-college life and memories to last forever. Not a bad deal at all.

If the adults in charge could just make some halfway decent decisions, all would be rosy. Instead, policies and rules and finances all are tilted toward enhancing the lives of the people in charge.

Health care, for instance. Athletes injured while playing or practicing for their school – on the job? – are covered by university policies only as supplemental coverage. Family insurance kicks in first. That’s absurd; a cost-saving maneuver so schools can pay their athletic director extra money when some kid sweats his way to an NCAA wrestling title.

Or freedoms to switch schools. NCAA transfer policies are Draconian. Players on the Division I level are subjected to sitting out a season. I can understand that. I don’t agree with it, but I understand the reasoning. Trying to keep order. Trying to prevent mass exodus.

But schools are allowed to restrict transferring athletes from receiving scholarship aid elsewhere, even though scholarships are not four-year deals, but one-year agreements, with the schools holding the power to extend or eliminate. Some coaches don’t succumb to such restrictive tactics, but some do. We saw it with OSU quarterback Wes Lunt, who was limited by Mike Gundy to which schools Lunt could transfer and receive a scholarship. We saw it with quarterback Baker Mayfield, who wasn’t even on scholarship at Texas Tech but was restricted by Tech on where he could accept a scholarship.

Continue reading this story on the...

by Berry Tramel
Columnist
Berry Tramel, a lifelong Oklahoman, sports fan and newspaper reader, joined The Oklahoman in 1991 and has served as beat writer, assistant sports editor, sports editor and columnist. Tramel grew up reading four daily newspapers — The Oklahoman,...
+ show more


Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    Madeleine Albright Burns Conan O'Brien in Hilarious Twitter War
  2. 2
    NYPD officers seen discarding gloves, masks into garbage can near Ebola patient's apartment
  3. 3
    Senate Midterm Elections
  4. 4
    (NEW PHOTOS) Jennifer Lawrence buys 'romantic' home that Jessica Simpson sold last year
  5. 5
    Hospital Throws Mom Out for Breastfeeding
+ show more