Ruth Marcus: Susan Rice and double standards

BY RUTH MARCUS Published: December 1, 2012
Advertisement
;

Does gender — or does the supercharged combination of gender and race — play a role in the pre-emptive strikes on not-yet-Secretary of State nominee Susan Rice?

For perspective on this complex question, it helps to return to 1974 and the nomination of another woman, Alice Rivlin, to head the Congressional Budget Office.

As Rivlin tells the story, the office had just been created, she was selected by a search committee — and the House Budget Committee chairman made clear his adamant, gender-based opposition.

“Over his dead body was a woman going to run this organization,” Rivlin recalled at an Atlantic magazine “Women of Washington” lecture last year.

No one would say that today. No one, I'd venture, would even think it. A woman, after all, has been secretary of state for all but four of the last 16 years. During the male interregnum, the job was held by a black man. House Republicans are getting well-deserved grief right now because of the absence of women among committee chairs.

But to note the progress women have made is not to say that the problem of sexism has been erased. It persists in the shadows of consciousness. Its manifestations are more subtle than the over-my-dead-bodyism of Rivlin's experience.

The public dialogue has moved from denying any gender differences to celebrating them, to the advantage of women. Consider the self-congratulatory discussion over the record 20 women set to serve as senators next year. “Women tend to be problem solvers, we work together,” Minnesota Democrat Amy Klobuchar told CBS. “They didn't get there by swaggering around, they got there by getting things done.”

A lapsed political consultant, male, told me that the one candidate who might lure him back into the field would be a woman presidential nominee — because, he said, it will take a female president to solve the country's problems.

The model of female leader has morphed from Iron Lady to soft power. And the controversy over Rice stems in part from the fact that she does not fit comfortably into this model of collegial, nurturing, division-healing woman.

The adjectives used to describe her are fraught with sexist undertones. Blunt. Sharp-elbowed. Driven. Egotistical. Some of these terms come from her friends. No one thinks she would win Miss Congeniality.



Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    John Seigenthaler, longtime Tennessean editor, dies at 86
  2. 2
    Accused Boston bomber spoke of martyrdom before attack: FBI
  3. 3
    Oklahoma State alum sues Sports Illustrated over 'Dirty Game' series
  4. 4
    George Clooney rejects Mail apology
  5. 5
    Bomb threat at Lexington Correctional facilities under investigation
+ show more