Same-sex couples in Oklahoma case argue against state's right to define marriage

In last brief before oral arguments, couples tell federal appeals court that states don’t have the right to violate constitutional guarantees of due process and equal protection.
by Chris Casteel Modified: April 7, 2014 at 5:58 pm •  Published: April 7, 2014

— Attorneys for the lesbian couples who challenged Oklahoma’s ban on same-sex marriage filed their final brief with a federal appeals court Monday, arguing the Tulsa County court clerk is trying to invoke “a runaway vision of states’ rights” in saying that Oklahoma has the power to define marriage.

In arguing that states have the right to prohibit same-sex couples from getting married, or having their marriages recognized, the court clerk ignores the Civil War and post-Civil War changes to the U.S. Constitution that prevent states from depriving people of the basic guarantees of due process and equal protection, the attorneys argued.

U.S. District Judge Terence Kern in January struck down Oklahoma’s constitutional ban on same-sex marriage, ruling that Tulsa County Court Clerk Sally Howe Smith violated the 14th Amendment rights of Mary Bishop and Sharon Baldwin when she denied them a marriage license.

Smith appealed the decision to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver, which is hearing a similar case from Utah. Oral arguments are scheduled for Thursday in the Utah case and April 17 in the Oklahoma case.

The brief filed Monday focuses mostly on the aspect of the Oklahoma case that has gotten little attention since Kern’s ruling — whether the Oklahoma ban on recognizing same-sex marriages from other states also is unconstitutional.

Susan Barton and Gay Phillips, who were married in California, challenged the provision on recognition, but Kern ruled that Howe wasn’t the right person to sue.

Trending Now


  1. 1
    Oklahoma State's Justin Gilbert signs his rookie contract with the Cleveland Browns
  2. 2
    Tulsa police believe mother, teen son planned deaths together
  3. 3
    Kevin Durant asks for your basketball videos in Summer is Serious 2
  4. 4
    Big 12 basketball: Time, TV listing announced for Sooners' December game against Washington
  5. 5
    Lawsuit: 'Duck Dynasty' stole 'camo' idea
+ show more