Share “ScissorTales: Dilemma in Newtown, Conn.,...”

ScissorTales: Dilemma in Newtown, Conn., is familiar to OKC officials

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board Published: July 6, 2013

THOSE affected by the Newtown, Conn., shootings are facing a dilemma familiar to those impacted by the Oklahoma City bombing: How should officials distribute millions donated to support survivors and the community?

A Newtown-Sandy Hook Community Foundation fund contains $11.4 million. More than 70 funds in Newtown have raised more than $21 million total.

Now officials must decide who benefits from those donations. Should families of the 20 first-graders and six educators killed get most of the money? Or do children who survived, who may need years of therapy, deserve the lion's share? Should families of the adults killed get more since they lost a breadwinner whose income cannot otherwise be replaced?

Those questions are familiar to Oklahoma City Community Foundation officials, who faced similar quandaries when determining how to distribute Murrah bombing disaster relief funds. More than 1,000 survivors and victim's children have received $11.2 million in assistance, and money remains available for victims' continuing long-term needs.

Yet some have criticized the foundation, demanding an immediate payout of all remaining money. That plan could leave many bombing survivors, who continue to require mental health treatment, without the long-term ability to pay for those services.

In Newtown, some advocate creation of a national victims' “compassion fund” that would receive any money donated in response to all future tragedies with that cash then sent directly to those most affected.

Removing fund oversight from communities directly impacted by tragedy seems likely to amplify controversy, not reduce it. Debate over funding priorities will remain constant. As the Oklahoma City Community Foundation has found, no payout plan will ever be embraced by all.

Farm bill roulette

Congress is being urged to pass a bad farm bill that artificially increases consumer prices to prevent an even worse law from taking effect and driving up milk prices even more. Such is the state of affairs at the U.S. Capitol. If a new federal farm bill isn't enacted, the current version expires in a matter of months. At that time, a 1949 law kicks in that sets mandatory high prices for milk — as much as $6 per gallon. Dairy farmers worry that those exorbitant prices will destroy product demand. Yet many of the provisions of the proposed farm bill also force consumers to pay more — up to twice real market price for sugar. Here's an idea: If the 1949 milk law is so bad, why not repeal it? Instead, bad law is being used to motivate passage of other bad laws. Either way, consumers get gouged.

The span of progress

Decades of neglect left numerous Oklahoma bridges structurally deficient. Erasing that backlog can't happen overnight, but steady progress is occurring. A new report by Transportation for America proves it. In 2005, about 17 percent of bridges on state roads were structurally deficient. That year, lawmakers began directing additional funding to bridge repair. The amount provided this year was $352.1 million; that funding will continue increasing until $775 million is provided. As a result of repairs funded with this extra cash, just 8 percent of bridges on state roads today are now structurally deficient. Unfortunately, Oklahoma still ranks high for its share of deteriorating bridges. But that problem is mostly because of dilapidated bridges on city and county roads, not state roads. Ongoing problems must be addressed, but Oklahomans shouldn't overlook the dramatic improvement in state bridges. It's an achievement that once seemed almost impossible.

Dogs days delayed

Last month was the 34th-warmest June in Oklahoma since the start of record-keeping in 1895. Is this news? Yes, because we all expected a terrible summer three-peat. We may yet have one, but for now the news is that in much of the state June was only the 56th driest on record statewide and one of the wettest ever in some areas. As July 1 arrived, the forecast high for Oklahoma City was 82 while in Portland, Ore., it was expected to be 94 and in the southern Oregon city of Medford the thermometer was expected to hit 107. We know this won't last. We'll warm up. Portland will cool down. What's making the weather news this week are the baking temperatures of the Southwest, not the mild conditions in Oklahoma and Texas, the Heat Bowl of 2011 and 2012. In the green city of Portland, we're confident, extant belief in anthropogenic global warming has reached a fever pitch. Here? We're chilling out while we can and remembering that every year in Oklahoma brings weather challenges along with a few magnificent days.

Continue reading this story on the...

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board
The Oklahoman Editorial Board consists of Gary Pierson, President and CEO of The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Christopher P. Reen, president and publisher of The Oklahoman; Kelly Dyer Fry, editor and vice president of news; Christy Gaylord...
+ show more


  1. 1
    Real ID poses potential real problems for those with Oklahoma driver's licenses
  2. 2
    Charged Owasso police officer surrenders, appears in Nowata County District Court
  3. 3
    Hillary Clinton just laid out a sweeping gun-control plan
  4. 4
    When It Comes to Sharing on Social Media, Conversations Differ By Race
  5. 5
    Just in time: Longhorns, Sooners get their own TollTags
+ show more


× Trending opinion Article