Share “ScissorTales: Legislature often leaves...”

ScissorTales: Legislature often leaves tough choices to others

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board Published: February 23, 2013

A measure approved this week in a state House committee would let Oklahoma voters decide an issue that lawmakers refuse to. It's only the latest example of legislators punting on their responsibilities.

A joint resolution by Rep. Jeff Hickman, R-Fairview, would let voters decide whether the state should seek a $200 million bond issue to fix the Capitol and other buildings in the Capitol complex. The Legislature has spiked previous bond issue efforts over concerns about the state incurring additional debt.

An idea similar to Hickman's was floated during the 2012 session but didn't materialize. The argument was that the Capitol is “the people's building” and so they — not the men and women sent to Oklahoma City to represent them — should make the decision.


Last year a legislative task force abruptly stopped studying the idea of letting grocery stores and convenience stores sell wine and high-point beer. Off it went to a potential vote of the people. Lawmakers have shown no appetite for changing state law to allow cities and towns to enact their own smoking-related ordinances. Bills went nowhere last year and again this session. So now Gov. Mary Fallin is leading a petition drive to send the idea to a vote of the people.

Legislators have no problem pandering and passing feel-good bills, but they too often lack the fortitude to make the difficult choices their jobs require.

Doak faces lawmakers

State Insurance Commissioner John Doak's tenure has been marked by controversy. Now lawmakers appear ready to rein him in. Senate Bill 8, which prohibits investigators from operating specialized motor vehicles equipped and marked differently than other department vehicles, gained unanimous approval in a state Senate committee this week. Sen. Harry Coates, R-Seminole, said the legislation was in response to Doak having purchased police vehicles for his anti-fraud unit. Doak may have to sell those vehicles if SB 8 becomes law. Senators also discussed amending the legislation to prevent Doak's investigators from carrying firearms because of the precedent it would set for other state agencies. We were among those who questioned the need for Doak to spend more than $180,000 on everything from shotguns to police-package vehicles for his anti-fraud unit, noting his predecessor got the job done without such extravagance. It appears lawmakers had the same reaction.

Good call

In siding with Rex Duncan, district attorney for Osage and Pawnee counties, Oklahoma County Special Judge Donald Easter made a good call. In declining to appeal the judge's decision, Attorney General Scott Pruitt made a better one. After beginning his term as district attorney, Duncan was mobilized for military service in Afghanistan with the Oklahoma Army National Guard. A legal opinion issued by Pruitt's office declared Duncan vacated his elected position when he went on active duty, claiming it violated a state constitutional prohibition on holding two offices at the same time. Duncan took the issue to court, where Easter ruled that a federal law pre-empted state law and allowed Duncan to serve in the military without vacating his elected office. This is a victory for those serving in the military and for common sense. We're glad Pruitt isn't spending more taxpayer dollars on an appeal.

An exception for every rule

While urging lawmakers to allow cities to impose stricter regulations on smoking in public, advocates rightfully noted the health risks associated with tobacco, including secondhand smoke. We supported that bill, but every rule has an exception. The Daily Mail reports England native Clara Cowell just quit smoking (after 82 years) at age 102. Cowell had averaged two to three cigarettes per day — a lifetime total of 60,000 cigarettes. She only quit because relatives feared the ash might start a fire. Cowell lives independently, doesn't believe in medication, drinks a cup of tea with whiskey every day, and still enjoys dancing. We wouldn't recommend emulating Cowell's smoking habit; she's clearly beaten the odds. But her story shows why caution should be used before citing extreme individual cases to justify enactment of health policies impacting the entire public. For every horrible worst-case scenario, there's also an unbelievable-but-true best-case scenario.

Continue reading this story on the...

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board
The Oklahoman Editorial Board consists of Gary Pierson, President and CEO of The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Christopher P. Reen, president and publisher of The Oklahoman; Kelly Dyer Fry, editor and vice president of news; Christy Gaylord...
+ show more


  1. 1
    Petition Demands 'Maze Runner' Cast Apologize for Stealing Artifacts From Burial Site
  2. 2
    BP fined a record $20.8 billion for oil spill disaster
  3. 3
    Snowden: I'd go to prison to return to US
  4. 4
    U.S. Senate candidate admits to sacrificing goat, drinking its blood
  5. 5
    Babysitter who had sex with 11-year-old boy gets suspended sentence
+ show more


× Trending opinion Article