Share “ScissorTales: Oklahoma hypocrisy hunters...”

ScissorTales: Oklahoma hypocrisy hunters need to aim at a different target than Fallin

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board Published: November 9, 2013

GOV. Mary Fallin recently made waves when her office noted that A-F grading of public schools was the law. She said school officials needed to accept that reality. Fallin's detractors feigned outrage, arguing that the governor is hypocritical since she has resisted Obamacare, which is also the law of the land. Baloney!

The Supreme Court upheld Obamacare, but it also allowed states to opt out of Medicaid expansion. In declining to expand Medicaid, Fallin didn't violate the law; she operated within its parameters as defined by the courts.

The successful Insure Oklahoma program was slated for elimination under Obamacare. Fallin fought to preserve it, eventually winning a federal reprieve. President Barack Obama repeatedly promised that “if you like your insurance plan, you can keep it,” but it was Fallin who actually fought to make that promise a partial reality in Oklahoma by preserving Insure Oklahoma.

There are other distinctions worth noting. In supporting A-F grades for schools, Fallin is endorsing a simple proposition: Some schools are academically better than others, and the public should have easy access to that information. On the other hand, Obamacare is based on the idea that government officials should overhaul a major share of the national economy in a way that disrupts millions of people's lives, drives up costs, reduces access to health care and continues to leave millions uninsured.

Those are two very different propositions. The hypocrisy hunters need to train their fire on another target.

Bizarre logic

Former Oklahoma Democratic Party Chairman Ivan Holmes, now running for state superintendent, doesn't like the A-F grading of public schools. In a press release, Holmes declared that if the A-F grading system being used by the state had been in place when he was in school, he “probably would not have made it out of the third grade.” That seems less an indictment of A-F school grades than of Holmes' fitness for public office or most entry level jobs. Tacitly suggesting you don't have a true third-grade education is unlikely to inspire voter confidence. But Holmes' bizarre attack is hardly unique among status-quo proponents in education. Researchers at OU and OSU recently proclaimed A-F school grades were invalid partly because public schools had such little effect on student learning (we kid you not). It makes one wonder: Is there any line of attack these guys reject because “that might make us look foolish”?

Sensible change

A new state law is changing early voting in Oklahoma's state and federal elections. It's a good move that will reduce the chance for complications on Election Day. Instead of allowing early voting on the Friday/Monday before an election, early voting will now occur on the prior Thursday/Friday (and Saturdays for state and federal elections). It's important that county election board officials have the Monday before an election free, so they can focus fully on preparation instead of having to run early voting and conduct those preparations at the same time. The logistics of running an efficient statewide election are never easy. To reduce distractions facing workers one day in advance is reasonable. The new law maintains citizens' early voting access, but also makes it more likely that election officials can run a glitch-free Election Day. Lawmakers deserve praise for making this practical adjustment.

The race is on

Republican Gov. Mary Fallin finally has someone to run against next year, for whatever that's worth. This week, R.J. Harris of Norman announced he had established a campaign committee. Harris, 40, has twice run unsuccessfully — once as a Republican, once as an independent — for the U.S. House seat held by Tom Cole, R-Moore, and in 2012 sought the Libertarian Party's presidential nomination. He'll seek the governor's job as a Democrat, which pleases the head of the state Democratic Party, Wallace Collins. Collins had been trying to produce a candidate, perhaps out of concern that if no one stepped up, he would have to serve as Fallin's foil. Instead it'll be Harris. “It's just not a true and legitimate government that gets elected in 2014 if we don't have a choice,” he said. Spunk? Harris has it. A chance of winning? Nope.

Continue reading this story on the...

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board
The Oklahoman Editorial Board consists of Gary Pierson, President and CEO of The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Christopher P. Reen, president and publisher of The Oklahoman; Kelly Dyer Fry, editor and vice president of news; Christy Gaylord...
+ show more


  1. 1
    This map shows the biggest music festival in Oklahoma, other states
  2. 2
    Bristol Palin Slams Washington State Initiative to Give Free Birth Control to Minors
  3. 3
    Oregon pot stores sell more than $11 million in first 5 days
  4. 4
    Sigourney Weaver turns 66: Then and now
  5. 5
    Not Sucking in Their Seventies: Rock Lifers Go the Distance
+ show more


× Trending opinion Article