Senate amnesty bill a farce

Published: August 25, 2013

Bobby Stem's “Oklahoma case for immigration reform” (Point of View, Aug. 17) equates prosperity with having a large pool of poorly educated, unskilled laborers provided by the U.S. Senate's amnesty bill. To sweeten this pot, Stem cites many wonderful benefits — thousands of jobs, lowered national debt, trillions in increased output. Wow!

Sadly, he missed a few troublesome bits of reality. First, he confuses legal and illegal immigration, a common liberal affliction. Second, he cites Congressional Budget Office estimates of growth — the same CBO that estimated Obamacare would cost $900 billion and now costs $2 trillion-plus and climbing. Third, he avoids enumerating the cost of amnesty for a possible 30 million immigrants. Currently the cost of 11 million illegal immigrants is more than $300 billion for welfare type payments, medical, social services, incarceration and monies sent “home” to name a few. A Heritage Foundation study puts the cost of the Senate bill at $6.3 trillion. Hardly a boon.

The Senate bill is a farce. It enacts legalization before border security is in place. Whatever security requirements are in the bill are left up to the discretion of the Obama administration; any back tax obligations can be waived. It winks at felonious behavior, provides for a full spectrum of services and benefits and stresses an already shaky economy. Stem's nirvana isn't good for Oklahoma, the country and definitely not for real citizens.

Pete Lepo, Edmond

Trending Now


  1. 1
    Baylor's Shawn Oakman not impressed by OU's win over Alabama in Sugar Bowl
  2. 2
    Dez Bryant, three Sooners in NFL trade value top 50 (so far)
  3. 3
    Johnny Manziel's No. 2 leads NFL in jersey sales
  4. 4
    You're more likely to get a raise now
  5. 5
    Google has a plan to speed up the Web
+ show more