Share “Slain Watonga girl's cousin will be tried...”

Slain Watonga girl's cousin will be tried on first-degree murder charge

James “Icey” Daukei Jr., 21, is accused of killing his cousin, Rosalin Reynolds, 8. She was found dead March 23
BY SHEILA STOGSDILL Modified: August 15, 2011 at 8:48 pm •  Published: August 15, 2011

— The cousin of Rosalin Reynolds, 8, of Watonga, whose blood-soaked body was found by her father near a freshly dug hole in the ground, will stand trial in her stabbing death.

James “Icey” Daukei Jr., 21, is charged with first-degree murder.

The man is a cousin to Erma Daukei, Rosalin's mother.

The case was sent to trial Monday afternoon at the conclusion of a preliminary hearing that started that morning.

Investigators said James Daukei confessed he killed the child and was digging a hole in a field behind her apartment complex to bury the body when he was confronted by her father, Ralph Reynolds, the morning of March 23.

“The reported confession has come into question,” said Josh Lee, Daukei's attorney.

Lee declined to comment further.

Eight wounds

Rosalin's body had eight stab wounds including the fatal 4-inch wound that went through her heart and punctured her liver, medical examiners said.

District Attorney Mike Fields said four witnesses testified Monday — former neighbor Bradley Skinner, Watonga police officer Perry Rackley, Blaine County sheriff's Deputy Lonny Spiva and Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation agent Martin Solarzano.

Continue reading this story on the... has disabled the comments for this article.


Arraignment date is set

James “Icey” Daukei Jr. is due back in district court Sept. 15 for arraignment. District Attorney Mike Fields said he will decide by then whether he will seek the death penalty.


  1. 1
    Bus driver at Illinois River resort accused of doing Jell-O shots on trip, authorities say
  2. 2
    Dallas Zoo's World-Famous Giraffe Kipenzi Dies
  3. 3
    Matt Barnes on Serge Ibaka: 'He’s just dirty'
  4. 4
    Prosecutor: Body camera video in fatal shooting to be released today
  5. 5
    America's 10 best cities for pizza
+ show more