Share “Sovereign immunity doesn't preclude action...”

Sovereign immunity doesn't preclude action against tribal payday lenders

Crowe’s Andre Caldwell discusses what the ruling in a recent Federal Trade Commission case means to Indian tribes and consumers.
by Paula Burkes Modified: May 14, 2014 at 4:00 pm •  Published: May 13, 2014

Q&A with Andre B. Caldwell

Decision sets precedent, seeks to enforce fairer lending practices

Q: The Federal Trade Commission sought relief in the district court against several payday lenders owned by tribal entities for violating laws governing deceptive consumer practices, improper debt collection and truth in lending. Explain the facts of this case.

A: The FTC claimed that, since at least 2002, the lenders’ websites and loan documents represented that the lenders would withdraw consumers’ scheduled payments from their bank accounts when their loan was due, ultimately leading to fewer finance charges. However, in reality, the lenders were withdrawing payments on multiple occasions and assessing multiple finance charges, ultimately resulting in a higher total cost over the life of the loan than initially disclosed.

Q: Why is this particular enforcement action of note to tribal payday lenders?

A: This case is important because this is the first federal court opinion in an FTC action wherein a court ruled that the assertion of sovereign immunity by tribal entities was insufficient to defeat an FTC enforcement action. The district court ruled that the FTC Act was a law of general applicability not subject to the sovereign immunity defense. Moreover, while the FTC Act provides certain exceptions, tribal entities were not amongst those enumerated.

Continue reading this story on the...

by Paula Burkes
A 1981 journalism graduate of Oklahoma State University, Paula Burkes has more than 30 years experience writing and editing award-winning material for newspapers and healthcare, educational and telecommunications institutions in Tulsa, Oklahoma...
+ show more


  1. 1
    Perfect summer escapes for families
  2. 2
    Montreal allowed 24/7 store hours to attract tourists
  3. 3
    24 of the best pieces of advice ever given to graduates
  4. 4
    Here's who you should (and should not) accept on LinkedIn
  5. 5
    The 25 best cities for job seekers right now
+ show more