Speech rights clash with cruelty law

By McClatchy-Tribune Information Services. Published: April 21, 2009
Advertisement
;

/> "Graphic depictions of the torture and maiming of animals” has "no place in a civilized society,” the lawyers said in a brief. But critics of the measure said it is too broad and potentially could make it illegal to broadcast scenes of hunting or bullfighting.

All 50 states have laws against animal cruelty and dog fighting. In 1999, Congress moved to combat an underground trade in videos that showed vicious dogs fighting each other and mauling helpless animals.

The measure made it a crime to make, sell or own images of "animal cruelty” for the purpose of making money. It referred to depictions where a "living animal is intentionally maimed, mutilated, tortured, wounded or killed” where such conduct would be illegal. It included exceptions for depictions that have serious religious, scientific, educational or artistic value.

Aguments in the case will be set for the fall.


NewsOK.com has disabled the comments for this article.

ALSO ...
Other decisions

On Monday, the Supreme Court:


• Said it will rule on an effort by prosecutors in Iowa to end a civil rights lawsuit against them by two men whose convictions for killing a retired police officer were set aside.


• Stepped into a dispute over how to determine when the Constitution’s guarantee of a speedy criminal trial has been violated.


• Refused an appeal from an inmate in Texas over jurors’ consultation of a Bible in the course of their deliberations on his sentence.


• Heard arguments in an Arizona case over ongoing federal court supervision of the state’s programs for English learners.

Trending Now


AROUND THE WEB

  1. 1
    Perspective: What's wrong with 'Black Jesus'?
  2. 2
    OU football: Eric Striker No. 52 on ESPN's top 100 college football players
  3. 3
    VIDEO: Adorable 5-Year-Old Really Doesn't Want Her Baby Brother to Grow Up
  4. 4
    'The Bachelorette' Star Josh Murray Is More Than 'Former Pro Baseball Player'
  5. 5
    Pauley Pavilion flooded after massive water main break at UCLA
+ show more