Share “State education board needs to reach...”

State education board needs to reach compromise on student appeals information

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board Published: June 11, 2012

CONTROVERSY hit the state Education Department again last week, but not for quite the reason we might have expected.

The state Board of Education met in special session to consider whether a handful of students should be awarded a high school diploma even though they hadn't passed tests required under the 2005 Achieving Classroom Excellence law. The potential for drama existed, but no students appeared individually before the board to plead their case. The board heard comments from two school officials and then considered documents presented as part of the student appeals. Their debate was in executive session.

The drama came after the meeting when the department decided to post the appeals documents on its website. The information included students' names, test score data, letters from students and their parents, and whether the students have disabilities. The backlash was almost immediate.

Even though state schools Superintendent Janet Barresi defended the practice through a spokesman, saying students or their parents had signed away privacy rights as part of the appeal process, state board members apparently weren't thrilled. By week's end, spokesman Damon Gardenhire said the practice would change based on the board's wishes.

We understand the hesitance of state board members. The Family Educational Records and Privacy Act (FERPA) is serious business and designed to protect students. As state board members, protecting those students is a top priority and it should be. Even the state's most-quoted advocate of open records said FERPA trumps the state's open records law and the information shouldn't be released in a way that identifies students.

It's hard not to question the sincerity of school officials who cry foul at every turn and were more than happy to share students' stories when it suited their purposes. But their sincerity isn't the issue here.

It's equally hard to understand why state education officials didn't take greater care to make clear the ways in which they would use a FERPA waiver to share student information. We'll leave to lawyers the matter of whether students even need a FERPA waiver to have their appeal heard by the state board.

Continue reading this story on the...

by The Oklahoman Editorial Board
The Oklahoman Editorial Board consists of Gary Pierson, President and CEO of The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Christopher P. Reen, president and publisher of The Oklahoman; Kelly Dyer Fry, editor and vice president of news; Christy Gaylord...
+ show more


  1. 1
    Judge declines divorce case, citing gay marriage ruling
  2. 2
    Crowdfunding For Real Estate: Buyer Beware
  3. 3
    10 affordable countries that budget travelers can't miss
  4. 4
    These wearables double as travel gadgets
  5. 5
    Police return woman’s stolen car — with drugs, weapons added
+ show more


× Trending opinion Article