Why was 3-year-old returned?
Child safety: Drowning raises DHS questions
After seeing house, officer thought: ‘I'm not leaving here without these children. They are coming with me.'DA says it's too

By Randy Ellis and Augie Frost Modified: May 25, 2007 at 12:39 pm •  Published: March 24, 2007
A 3-year-old boy who drowned in a bathtub Wednesday was returned to his southeast Oklahoma City home two days earlier at the recommendation of a Department of Human Services social worker, the Oklahoma County district attorney said Friday.

"I'm really questioning the judgment of the social worker at this time,” District Attorney David Prater said. "I want to see the reports, since verbal assurances were made ... by the social worker. DHS is the investigative body we've got to rely on in deprived-child cases. They are our eyes and ears.

"It's a terrible case, and I'm really sick about what happened,” he said.

Oklahoma City police officers said the boy and two siblings were removed from the home March 16 because of deplorable living conditions.

Police officer Anne Folmar said the minute she walked into a southeast Oklahoma City home that day, one thought gripped her mind.

"I'm not leaving here without these children,” she said. "They are coming with me.”

The overwhelming stench, trash, loose electrical wires, moldy pizza and other debris made it obvious it was not a safe place for kids, she said.

Folmar and police Staff Sgt. Dale Frazier say they did their job that day by removing the three small children from the home and placing them in a state Department of Human Services shelter.

Three days later, the three kids — ages 5, 3 and 4 months — were returned to the home. Two days after that, 3-year-old William Barnard drowned in the home's bathtub. William had Down syndrome.

Prater said Friday that Jane Brown, the experienced head of the juvenile division in his office, followed the recommendation of a Department of Human Services social worker when she released the children to go back home before the death.

The DHS worker said improvements had been made on the house, and the family had agreed to accept in-home services to improve parenting and housekeeping skills, Prater said.

DHS spokesman George Johnson refused to identify the social worker involved, saying that information was confidential. Brown did not return a telephone call seeking comment

Just how much the house had been improved is a question that haunts people involved with the case.

NewsOK.com has disabled the comments for this article.

Related documents

William Barnard The 3-year-old drowned this week in a bathtub at his southeast Oklahoma City home. PHOTO PROVIDED

Trending Now


  1. 1
    Report: Caron Butler close to two-year deal with Detroit Pistons
  2. 2
    It’s harder to be a poor student in the U.S. than in Russia
  3. 3
    Man fatally stabbed in west Tulsa early Sunday
  4. 4
    How brain imaging can be used to predict the stock market
  5. 5
    Bridenstine tours Fort Sill, satisfied with facility's transparency
+ show more